It’s not generally our business to comment on the travails of Pittsburgh’s sports teams, but sometimes they get so extreme that they become civic matters relevant to the entire city. We are, once again, at that point with the Pittsburgh Pirates.
During Tuesday night’s game against the Boston Red Sox, outspoken Hall of Fame pitcher and Red Sox color commentator Dennis Eckersley dropped one of those throwaway lines that sticks in the mind, because it expresses the truth so well. Noting that the Pirates’ lineup was unlike any other team’s in the league, not only in its current struggles but in its lack of potential, he called the team “a hodgepodge of nothingness.”
Taking nothing away from the hard work of individual players who are trying to make the most of this moment in their careers, Mr. Eckersley is obviously correct. The Pittsburgh Pirates are not a serious major league franchise. The reason? The owner won’t spend what serious baseball requires.
As we’ve emphasized before, this isn’t just a matter of grief for fans. Pittsburgh’s sports teams are community assets, and when their stewards treat them as nothing more than profit-generating machines, it hurts the entire community. At least part of the point of the city’s baseball franchise is to provide compelling entertainment and displays of excellence. Even on that standard, far below genuine competitive success, the Pirates fall short.
If the leaders of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra were to allow the ensemble to degrade to the point where it played off-key every night, it would also hurt the city as a whole. Thank goodness that under the leadership of a competent board and maestro Manfred Honeck, there is no chance of that happening.
But this has been a consistent problem for the Pirates under owner Bob Nutting. The hiring of ex-Red Sox general manager Ben Cherington and ex-Penguins team president Travis Williams inspired some optimism, and some of the young players show promise and the franchise’s farm system has modestly improved. But day-to-day, the franchise remains an embarrassment to the city.
In Mr. Eckersley’s words, it’s “ridiculous” and “pathetic.” While Mr. Nutting has wheeled and dealed in recent months, selling his mountain resorts for $125 million and buying upstart Pittsburgh distillery Wigle Whiskey and its sister company, Threadbare Cider & Mead, the Pirates remain near the basement of the major leagues (28th out of 30 teams) in payroll.
Spending doesn’t always correlate with success. Just ask this year’s Red Sox — but then look at last year’s Red Sox. Choosing not to spend is choosing to fail. And that fails not just baseball fans, but the entire city.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.