Even though it involves millions of taxpayer dollars, compelling court testimony in a dispute between the Allegheny County Airport Authority and the company that operates the airport’s Airmall concessions has been closed to the public.
At issue is whether the Airport Authority’s claims of incompetence against Fraport Pittsburgh, specifically regarding violations of security protocols, are a sufficient reason to terminate the concessionaire’s lease or simply a ruse to escape the contract.
Despite the overriding public interest in the proceedings, Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward twice closed them during a hearing over an injunction that would restore Fraport’s contract.
Post-Gazette reporter Mark Belko, rightly, objected on both occasions to this violation of open government. The first time, Judge Ward summoned a sheriff’s deputy to escort Mr. Belko from the courtroom. He returned later when testimony moved on to other topics.
Judge Ward told the Post-Gazette it can appeal to unseal the record. By then, however, the case will be over.
Access delayed is access denied. The right of the public to the justice system’s proceedings, especially in cases involving public agencies, demands that the court open the proceedings now. (Worse, the Airport Authority had petitioned the court to keep the entire hearing private. To her credit, Judge Ward dismissed that motion.)
The first episode of private testimony involved details of Fraport’s alleged misconduct. The Airport Authority argued the testimony would reveal sensitive security information, without specifying why. The burden of proof to close testimony lies with the party requesting it — and that burden is heavy, said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association.
The second episode was based on testimony about a “human resources issue,” an even weaker rationale for closing public proceedings. Embarrassing personal testimony comes with the territory; if every potentially reputation-damaging revelation were off-limits to the public, it would be permanently barred from any judicial proceeding.
If this were a dispute between private parties, the bar for closing the courtroom would be lower. This case, however, involves a public agency.
Judge Ward’s actions set a bad precedent for public access and open government. When the case recommences this coming week, all testimony — especially that of Airport Authority CEO Christina Cassotis — must open to the public. The people have a compelling interest to hear and scrutinize it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.