Pennsylvania’s new tax credit for child care expenses, while generally helpful, unfairly restricts benefits to families who choose outside child care. The policy disregards the costs and work taken on by stay-at-home parents and other family members. In fairness, the policy should include a smaller standard credit for those families.

Any sound social policy must recognize the nation’s diverse family structures. In some families, both parents work to make ends meet, or because they choose to do so. Other families must keep one parent at home or prefer to do so. One parent might suffer a disability, for example, or both parents might believe that it’s best for the kids to have a parent at home. Sometimes children are cared for by extended families — friends, grandparents or other relatives — especially in poor or single-parent households.

The state should not pick winners and losers among them; instead, it ought to enact policies that are fair to all families. A 2015 Pew study showed two-working-parent households already earn about 85% more than those with one working parent. A family with two full-time workers, making twice the state’s median household income, will get a tax credit, but a single mother making poverty wages who relies on her mother for childcare will get nothing.

To be sure, child care outside the home is expensive, but caring for kids at home is not cheap, either. Besides giving up the stay-at-home-parent’s potential wages, parents must pay for food, supplies, day camp fees and assorted other expenses the state now subsidizes for those who choose outside child care. .

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Child and Dependent Care Enhancement Program will offer a fully refundable credit — up to $3,000 — for care costs for one child, and up to $6,000 for two. The credit’s amount will be indexed to income and based on some proportion of the expenses claimed for the federal child care credit, which phases out at the $150,000 income level for married filers and half that for single filers.

The solution is to offer a smaller standard credit — say, $250 for one dependent and $500 for two or more — to families who choose to keep care in the family. That change wouldn’t unduly burden the program, while providing a boost to many Pennsylvania families who need one.

Making child care more affordable is a laudable goal — but all child care should count.