It’s a miracle for the City of Pittsburgh that no one died when the Fern Hollow Bridge collapsed on January 28. The City of Pittsburgh would have been morally, and likely legally and financially, responsible.
A flawed design, long-term deferred maintenance and neglectfulness of seemingly small issues weakened the bridge beyond its ability to survive. Some of the inspection reports did not issue their warnings with sufficient urgency.
But the new information reviewed by the Post-Gazette investigative team led by Sean D. Hamill strongly suggests that the City of Pittsburgh most failed in its basic duty to keep people safe on its thoroughfares.
The list of recommendations made by state inspectors and ignored by the city’s infrastructure bureaucracy is staggering. The city can plausibly say that it couldn’t afford a multimillion-dollar rehabilitation of the bridge.
But it couldn’t afford $9,000 to drill holes in essential beams to slow the progress of cracks? $48,000 to paint exposed steel to slow corrosion? $500 — yes, $500 — to clear clogged drains that forced corroding water and road salt through cracks in the superstructure? For all of these, inspectors noted “work not planned.”
The decision not to do the work wasn’t a problem of funding. The city had the money and the moral responsibility to spend it. It was, and is, a question of basic competence.
While PennDOT’s redactions of the inspection reports continue to be overbroad, we are grateful that more and more information from those reports is coming to light. In the process, the government entity that has shared the least information with the public — the city — is looking most at fault.
The City of Pittsburgh can’t hide behind its pending lawsuits: the public’s sense of its own safety on city bridges, not to mention other infrastructure, depends on a transparent accounting of how the city handled, or didn’t handle, the Fern Hollow inspection reports.
The responsibility to release these documents falls on Mayor Ed Gainey, but it would be unfair to blame his administration for the problem. The ignored inspection recommendations go back to the late 1990s and the mayoralty of Tom Murphy.
But the most serious decay occurred on the watch of Bill Peduto. He should answer questions about how the city handled infrastructure inspections when he was mayor: Did the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure choose to ignore repair recommendations out of the mistaken belief that they weren’t important, or did they fail to notice the problems to begin with?
Until the city opens its own books, we are left in the terrible position of wondering: Which bridge is next? Many city bridges look worse than Fern Hollow. How many of those have decades of damning inspections tagged “work not planned”? How long do the people of Pittsburgh have to take a deep breath and mutter a prayer before going to work, running errands or visiting family?
The city knows. It needs to tell its people, now. And then start fixing the bridges.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.