Move over "American Idol" and "The Voice," yet another music competition show debuted this week on NBC.
Inspired by "Eurovision," "American Song Contest" is purportedly about state pride and pitting representatives from the 50 states, five territories and Washington D.C. against one another in a musical bloodbath — all in pursuit of a yet-to-be-revealed prize to be awarded May 9.
What “American Song Contest” shows is that the world’s major exporter of pop culture struggles as an importer. Unlike the still diverse cultures of Europe, the cauldron that produced America’s pop music industry has swallowed whole the mixed ingredients that make up the nation’s music scene.
"Eurovision” stretches back to the 1950s, holding the Guinness title for longest-running song contest. It rides on a successful formula of blending nationalism with kitsch, often resulting in discordant, gaudy but weirdly riveting performances. It’s true that famous names like ABBA, Celine Dione and Olivia Newton-John have participated, but for the most part it’s more spectacle than substance and almost embarrassingly fun.
Global tensions erupting with Russia's invasion of Ukraine remind us music and culture can be instruments for unity and national pride. Days after Russia invaded Ukraine, hackers targeted Russian television stations to broadcast Ukrainian music. Meantime, Ukrainian musicians are broadcasting the state anthem and traditional tunes to promote unity.
"American Song Contest" is a more lighthearted attempt at unifying Americans through song and spectacle. Monday's debut episode featured acts representing 11 states, including Oklahoma, Connecticut and Wyoming. It kicked off with a March Madness, BBQ wings and brackets feel.
The music industry, through streaming services like Spotify, SoundCloud and Apple Music, blends, mixes, samples and borrows. Fusions of country, rap, K-pop and more top the charts, before the internet jumps frenetically to its next obsession. This poses a problem for “American Song Contest”: No state or genre in 2022 can, with a straight face, claim to own its pop music.
Not that the show doesn’t try its hardest. To draw lines and keep things interesting, before each performance it fronted a montage of each artist's relationship to his or her state, explaining how it contributed to the song. The music, however, was hardly surprising, except to those viewers who actually expected country songs from Oklahoma or folk from Indiana. Oklahoma's Alexa delivered a K-pop hit, while Indiana's UG skywalkin, born in East Africa, came out swinging with his own brand of hip hop.
It’s all pretty predictable. Attempts by the show to tie the music to a state or territory just don’t work. The links feel like generic add-ons, as co-host Kelly Clarkson dons a cheese-hat to talk with the Wisconsin performer, Jack'O, who cracks jokes about R&Brie. Snoop Dogg, Ms. Clarkson's co-host, proclaims the show is a chance for performers to "Show America what your state is made of." But there's little real difference between the country that comes from Arkansas and any other state.
Cashing in on state pride by singing from an American song book doesn’t work. Still, the show much go on, even as nationalist fervors threaten to engulf the world in war.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.