Since Allegheny County’s Port Authority started enforcing a COVID-19 vaccine mandate Wednesday, most unvaccinated employees, including bus and rail operators, have gotten their first shot. The remaining holdouts are likely now beyond persuasion but could still change their minds, especially when their livelihoods — not to mention pensions — are on the line. The agency ought to be lenient toward last-minute holdouts and other terminated employees, offering those who get vaccinated a chance to return to work.

With more foresight, the Port Authority probably could have avoided this confrontation. The authority is well within its rights, as a public agency and a purveyor of public services, to impose an enforceable vaccine mandate. And, morally, the move is justified by even a small increase in protection against transmission of the virus. Operators are in close quarters daily with numerous riders.

To balance its duties to public health, employees and customers, however, the authority might have struck a compromise that allowed more operators to remain active, without compelling them to to violate their beliefs, even if those beliefs were unfounded. Instead, the Port Authority flexed its muscles to enforce a strict vaccine mandate.

The Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85 reports that more than 40 employees had received religious or health exemptions to the vaccine mandate. The authority subjects these employees to onerous testing requirements, but has allowed them to keep their jobs and continue serving the public. It could have extended this option to other vaccine holdouts, at least temporarily, especially while COVID cases are at a historic low and public health agencies are lifting restrictions.

Advertise with us

Fortunately, service disruptions could have been far worse, especially for the elderly, public school students and others with limited alternatives. Transit uncertainty, potentially, means missed medical appointments and lost jobs or wages. Further service interruptions should subside soon, as most suspended operators return to work. The authority’s offer of a week of free rides was a thoughtful gesture to compensate customers for temporary inconveniences.

The pandemic exposed and exacerbated not only gaps in access to medical care among Americans, but also differences in values, priorities and beliefs.  Employers should try to accommodate those differences, while still promoting the general welfare. As the COVID era shifts from pandemic to endemic status, lingering uncertainty and the common good require ongoing vigilance.