Last year, UPMC, as a “nonprofit,” brought in $1.46 billion more than it spent. The health care and health insurance giant now sits on $10.7 billion in cash and investments.

Something’s out of whack.

A nonprofit organization like UPMC, with legal and economic privileges, ought to serve a public purpose. To do that, it must commit to reinvesting more of its “excess revenue” in the community.

Tax-exempt status, especially in health care, is really a public subsidy — in effect, a preemptive tax refund — to help organizations serve the health care needs of everyone in a community, whether or not they can pay for them. It is not to ensure a glittering and far-reaching expansion of a health care brand.

Advertise with us

To be fair, UPMC reports $1.7 billion in “community benefits,” including more than $500 million each in pro bono care and charitable contributions. It was a founding contributor to the groundbreaking Pittsburgh Promise scholarship program and sponsors innumerable events and programs around the region.

But all that doesn’t mean its business practices should escape scrutiny.

In the end, that $1.46 billion in definitely-not-profits comes from the markup: the amount UPMC charges patients and insurance companies above what it costs UPMC to do business.

(Those charges to insurance companies, by the way, are passed along to patients in the form of higher premiums.)

In other words, it’s the most, or nearly the most, that UPMC can wring from childhood therapy, middle-age knee replacements, old-age memory care and so on.

Advertise with us

To be sure, nonprofits have a right — even a responsibility — to take in more than they spend. Making enough money to fund innovative research and state-of-the-art facilities is essential to UPMC’s public purpose.

But $1.46 billion is more than $600 for each man, woman and child in the Pittsburgh region. And that’s only for one year.

To UPMC executives, this kind of excess revenue probably looks like success. To everyone outside the board room, however, it’s a clear sign that something’s misaligned with UPMC’s priorities and, more broadly, with this nation’s health care system.

It’s time for UPMC, once again, to demonstrate its good faith. Set aside some of that excess revenue for patients and the community. Negotiate with Mayor Ed Gainey for a payment in lieu of taxes. Just 2% of last year’s excess would pay for the Fern Hollow Bridge replacement, with millions to spare.

UPMC also should consider what could be called a patient dividend. A mutual life insurance company returns some of its profits to its members every year. Likewise, distributing some consistent share of excess revenue through lower prices and debt forgiveness would go a long way toward reestablishing trust in UPMC’s public purpose.

UPMC is an extraordinary health care organization; with a realignment in how it does business, it can also be an extraordinary corporate citizen.