The food is beautiful. Exquisite, really. Almost everything chef Kevin Sousa plates up feels like it would be at home in a museum, with every detail intentionally and meticulously organized.
That’s not the way the businesses attached to his food have turned out, however.
Now, there’s nothing unusual or noteworthy about a businessman’s ventures going belly up, even if it’s a frequent occurrence. This is especially true in the restaurant industry, where the majority of new openings fold in the first year.
What’s different with Mr. Sousa, however, is the way his projects fail — usually after big promises for neighborhood renewal and often after attracting public or foundation funding.
It started with Salt of the Earth on Penn Avenue in Garfield, on the border with East Liberty, at the very beginning of the wave of interest and development that has since swept those neighborhoods. At the time, choosing that location was maverick and risky, and Mr. Sousa was awarded a $150,000 Urban Redevelopment Authority loan to help to make it work.
In retrospect, this was probably the high-water mark. Salt of the Earth received glowing reviews from this newspaper and from outlets around the nation and the globe. It served 10,000 customers in its first 60 days. On every visible measure, it was a smashing success.
But Mr. Sousa split from his business partners, who assumed responsibility for that URA loan, after only a few years. He had turned his attention to two other East Liberty projects, but neither lasted, and both left behind debts that others cleaned up.
Yet it seemed by the mid-2010s that all those projects had been leading up to Mr. Sousa’s greatest act yet: Superior Motors in Braddock. He raised $300,000 on Kickstarter and received personal and financial support from then-Mayor John Fetterman, who mediated hundreds of thousands in foundation grants and low-interest loans through his nonprofit, Braddock Redux. After years of delays, it opened in 2017.
The promises were huge: urban farming, job training, a culinary school, a catalyst for revitalizing the entire town. Again, the food triumphed. And again, the rest floundered, with mixed (at best) reviews from neighbors, including current Braddock Mayor Chardaé Jones, who found the outreach and benefits to be far less compelling than what was pledged.
Superior Motors closed for good during the pandemic, though there is hope that one of Mr. Sousa’s business partners will breathe new life into it soon. The chef, once again, moved on — now to the Hilltop neighborhoods south of the rivers, with promises to Mount Oliver and Allentown that, here, his visions were fully formed and would bear fruit for the wider community.
Mr. Sousa has now left Mount Oliver Bodega two months into its run after being panned by community members and, reportedly, his own partners for insisting on $40 pizzas. The restaurant has now closed indefinitely to figure out a new model. The fate of Mr. Sousa’s Arlington Beverage Club, set to open early next year in a revamped social club that once belonged to St. George parish, is anybody’s guess.
The truth is that destination dining in general — and the flighty Mr. Sousa in particular — doesn’t always deliver results for struggling communities. It’s time to stop indulging quixotic celebrities and gauzy fantasies: Neighborhood renewal is simply more weight than food, no matter how fabulous, can carry.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.