On Jan. 16, 1874, the New York Times reported that “a meeting of prominent Pennsylvanians resident in this City was held yesterday at the Astor House, for the formation of a Pennsylvania society.”

The newspaper continued: “Mr. Jerome Buck announced the objects of the proposed society as partly benevolent, and partly social, the social element to predominate, and an epoch in the history of Pennsylvania to be celebrated annually by a reunion.”

Mr. Buck’s proclamation has proved prophetic, in multiple respects.

Today begins in earnest this year’s reunion of the Pennsylvania Society, which has morphed from a dinner for Keystone ex-pats into a weekend-long Big Apple blowout for thousands of the commonwealth’s power brokers and their hangers-on — and the social does indeed predominate.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Society itself dates its founding to a later dinner, in December 1899, not at the Astor House but at the Waldorf-Astoria, perhaps to justify the venerable tradition of hosting the annual dinner at that symbol of luxury. (The Astor was razed in 1926; meanwhile, due to years of renovations at the Waldorf, the Society has been slumming it at the Midtown Hilton since 2017.)

In itself, the Pennsylvania Society isn’t much, hewing remarkably closely to Mr. Buck’s 1874 sound byte to the Times: It’s a social catalog of the who’s who of the commonwealth, and it throws an annual dinner to celebrate the Keystone State — and, let’s be honest, mostly one another — in Manhattan. The irony that Pennsylvania apparently has nowhere special enough to celebrate how special we are is lost on no one.

By now, however, the phrase “Pennsylvania Society” has mostly come to mean the event itself — not just the black-tie dinner, but the hundreds of breakfasts, lunches, dinners, receptions, panels, speeches, strip shows, bar crawls and fistfights, scheduled or unscheduled, that emanate out from the Waldorf (or the Hilton) and occupy several square blocks of Manhattan in the name of Penn’s Woods.

If you can name a corporation, law firm or politician with a major presence in Pennsylvania, there is an event with their name on it.

Now, we don’t begrudge anyone a good party. And, in truth, there’s something to be said for social events where Democrats and Republicans, corporate executives and union leaders, committed conservatives and passionate progressives, and Penguins fans and Flyers hooligans can meet on equal terms, without having to perform for an audience, and just talk — or, you know, mumble and slur, depending on how far into the afternoon, er, night it is. Affability — the virtue of simply getting along — is a good thing, and the first step to mutual understanding.

Advertise with us

Yet it’s hard not to see events like the Pennsylvania Society as an inside joke the rest of us aren’t in on. It’s a boozy weekend in another (more powerful) state where this state’s elite go off to revel and to make plans and deals and alliances that could affect the regular people of Pennsylvania small-s society for years, even decades to come.

And yet the participants rarely acknowledge to us, or even to themselves, that this is really what they’re up to. If you’re going to party like an old-fashioned, decadent, self-satisfied elite, don’t turn around and throw up campaign ads dressed in flannel and denim. Own it.

Or you can always stay home.