Before the spring Democratic primary, we endorsed state Rep. Ed Gainey over incumbent Mayor Bill Peduto and retired police officer Tony Moreno.

Since that time, Mr. Gainey has prevailed in the primary, Mr. Peduto has carried on his (now lame-duck) mayoralty, and Mr. Moreno has continued his campaign on the Republican ticket after securing that party’s nomination with write-in votes.

While we have been impressed with Mr. Moreno’s rise from apparent gadfly to serious and articulate competitor, not enough has changed since the spring for us to change our endorsement: We encourage Pittsburghers to select Mr. Gainey, the veteran East End legislator, to succeed Mr. Peduto as mayor on Tuesday.

Mr. Gainey knows the city from all sides. From inside its government looking out: He served substantive roles in the administrations of both Tom Murphy and Luke Ravenstahl. From other governments looking in: He has served the 24th Legislative District for eight years in Harrisburg and understands the tricky relationship between city and state.

Advertise with us

From the perspective of those who have always thrived here: His district includes Highland Park and parts of Shadyside and Regent Square. From the perspective of those who have always struggled here: His district also includes Homewood and Larimer and Lincoln-Lemington.

From the halls of power: He knows how to navigate challenging relationships and to broker consensus — or at least compromise. And, most importantly, from the streets where the real people of the city live and work and play: He was born in the Hill District, moved to South Oakland, settled in East Liberty and now makes his home in Lincoln-Lemington.

Will Mr. Gainey fix everything? Probably not. But we approve of his priorities, especially taking on the miserliness of Pittsburgh’s enormous “nonprofits” and moving toward a community policing model. However, we would like to see more brass tacks — snow removal, blight, basic cleanliness — and fewer abstractions. That, we hope, will come with experience in the office.

Should Mr. Gainey prevail, we urge Mr. Moreno to continue to serve the city as a tough but respectful alternative voice who will keep the mayor on his toes. But right now, it’s Ed Gainey’s turn to run the show, and we warmly recommend him to voters.

Also on Tuesday, there are two live races for the Pittsburgh Board of Public Education. In both cases, Democratic incumbents lost their primaries but will appear on the Republican ballot after having cross-filed in the spring.

Advertise with us

In District 5, incumbent Terry Kennedy has not campaigned to keep her seat. And so we recommend Tracey Reed, of Greenfield, to succeed her.

In District 9, on the other hand, incumbent Veronica Edwards is contesting Tuesday’s election against Gene Walker, who won the May primary. In that race, we endorse the newcomer, Mr. Walker of Brighton Heights.

Mr. Walker will bring an outsider’s perspective, but with an insider’s knowledge of the district’s issues, to the board. His professional experience developing and executing in-school programs with the Pittsburgh Promise, along with his personal experience shepherding his children through the city’s public schools, will allow him to jump into the job confidently on day one.

But more importantly for the struggling district, Mr. Walker will not be constrained by the way things have always been done. In his interview with the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, he was most impressive when he spoke with candor about the ways the Pittsburgh Public Schools has failed the city’s children. His ideas for the district were creative and even courageous; he was willing to go beyond cliches and describe bold proposals that would anger many — but there can be no meaningful reform without risk.

He also showed growth from the primary election when he excluded the possibility of closing schools. Now he acknowledges that right-sizing the district’s real estate footprint, as part of a comprehensive plan with community input, likely will be necessary. Don’t call this a flip-flop. Call it wisdom — or coming to terms with reality.

Advertise with us

The incumbent, Ms. Edwards, is a passionate advocate for children’s well-being. We applaud her commitment to character education and her crusade to get Pittsburgh kids safely back into the classroom for this school year. But she is simply overmatched here. Her vision for PPS is constrained by the status quo; it seems that her admirable four decades of service to the district has left her unable to see the necessity of bold and new solutions.

For District 9, the Post-Gazette recommends Mr. Walker.