The first Eradicate Hate Global Summit wrapped up Wednesday at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center. As promised, the participants agreed to consider solutions that could be delivered in time for next year’s event, though the specific choices will be confirmed in the coming weeks and are somewhat vague.
But we can hardly be too critical: Eradicating hate is rather like eradicating sin, and no church or other religious (or secular) group has managed the task over the past several thousand years. Some patience is called for.
In following the progress of the summit, however, we were inspired with a notion for next year’s edition: Perhaps there could be a parallel focus, alongside combating already-existing communities of hate, on preventing hate in the first place.
Any botanist will tell you that it’s a lot easier to prevent weeds from developing than it is to uproot an infestation once it’s taken root. This doesn’t mean we ignore the already-existing problem — only that we also keep an eye on the conditions that allow the problem to get worse.
And so, what are the conditions that allow hate to find a home in the human soul? What are the deprivations that leave a dark, fertile home for hate to flourish?
We’d like to propose two: the deprivation of meaning, and the deprivation of hate’s perfect opposite — love.
Viktor Frankl wrote “Man’s Search for Meaning” one year after the end of the Second World War, much of which he spent in German concentration camps. It’s one of the most popular books of the 20th century and a touchstone of modern psychology. His basic theory is this: The primary motivating force to a flourishing human life is not pleasure or power, as others would have it, but meaning.
Deprived of meaning, humans can lose the will to live well, or to live at all. And so some people, deprived of all the usual sources of meaning — friendships, family ties, dignified and fairly-compensated work, belief in a purpose beyond oneself — find meaning in hate.
When Robert Bowers, the Tree of Life killer, infamously said on the fringe social media site Gab, “Screw your optics, I’m going in,” he was announcing the meaning he’d found for his life. And it was probably, in the most perverse way possible, thrilling.
This brings us to love. A person who loves and knows he is loved will never be able to organize his life around hatred. This is why, almost to a man, violent extremists do not usually come from healthy, intact families. Nor do they have close friends, at least in the real world: They find community, and a simulacrum of love and belonging, online.
We know that all this is at least as vague as the goals that emerged from the summit. But it’s just a starting point, and after all there are public policies that can help: We can organize the economy so that more people have dignified and meaningful work, and we can adjust incentives to create a more socially and financially supportive culture for families.
We may not be able to solve the soul, but we can begin to take care for the soul seriously. Maybe next year’s Eradicate Hate Global Summit can take up the task.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.