In a matter of weeks, the FDA is widely expected to approve the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine for children ages 5 to 11. This milestone will open a new front in the pandemic, boosting many Americans’ hopes that victory is getting closer. To this end, the White House has announced an aggressive rollout plan, with 15 million pediatric doses ready to ship and another 50 million already purchased.

While we share this hope, we’d like to temper it with a dose of reality.

Many parents will rush to the pharmacist or pediatrician the moment the FDA says so, but the truth is that many more — and not all vaccine skeptics, far from it — are not yet ready to have their younger children vaccinated. According to a CBS News poll from earlier this month, only 1 in 3 parents of 5- to 11-year-old kids will certainly take them in for the shot. Meanwhile, another third is dead set against it.

And in many cases, this isn’t about entire families getting, or avoiding, the vaccine. According to the same poll, only 60% of vaccinated parents are sure they will get the shot for their kids, and the same proportion of unvaccinated parents will refuse it for theirs. In other words, a great many parents are applying a different calculus to their children than they are to themselves.

Advertise with us

It would be a mistake to assume that this difference is irrational. For instance, there are parents who have a medical condition that makes the vaccine more dangerous for them, but who will gladly vaccinate their unaffected children. And there are parents who hustled to get their shots, but who do not feel the same urgency for their children, who are extremely unlikely to be seriously harmed by the virus.

We also shouldn’t forget the large number of people who have recovered from COVID-19 and therefore have some natural immunity. While evidence suggests that the vaccine can further boost that immunity, having natural COVID-19 antibodies changes the balance of pros and cons, especially for children.

All this should dampen enthusiasm among government and educational authorities for pediatric vaccine mandates. These policies are most effective when there is already significant buy-in among the target population. But with only one-in-three parents of preteen kids convinced that their children need to be vaccinated, imposing a mandate could further erode the credibility of the authorities — and not just among those in thrall to misinformation and conspiracy theories.

We continue to hope that the vaccines will bring us closer to the full resumption of everyday life for all, either by vanquishing COVID-19 or, more likely, by achieving a sustainable stalemate. And we are encouraged by the efficacy of the Pfizer dose in young people.

But that hope must be bounded by reality, and the reality is that children’s natural defenses have proven to be tremendously effective against COVID-19. The approval of a vaccine for preteen children is a milestone, to be sure, but not one that will radically alter the trajectory of the pandemic. Let’s not expect pediatric vaccines — or the children themselves — to shoulder more weight than they can bear.