Colin Powell may have been the last man or woman in American politics to command something close to universal respect.
Sure, he has always had his detractors. Many on the left had always been suspicious of his affiliation with Republican politicians. And many on the right regarded him as unreliably conservative — and they felt vindicated when he endorsed Barack Obama in 2008.
And his career wasn’t perfect: No one who has spent so long in the public eye, and made so many consequential decisions, will get them all right. Sometimes important people’s errors are very serious and have historic implications, such as Mr. Powell’s decision, as secretary of state under George W. Bush, to endorse before the United Nations claims that Saddam Hussein’s Iraq had enormous stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction.
Yet there used to be a sense among the American people that we shouldn’t judge a man only by his mistakes but by the overall conduct of his life and the fullness of his character. There used to be an understanding that we and our friends are not perfect, and therefore who fall short are not perfectly bad but simply human.
In that world, not too long ago, we could put aside our misgivings and say of a man like Colin Powell: “This is a man I respect, even if I disagree with him. This is a man I trust, even if not perfectly. This is a man who represents the best in America, even if he also reflects her flaws.”
Colin Powell was born in 1937 to Jamaican immigrants in Harlem. He didn’t thrive in school but did in the structure of the military and rose to become the youngest and first Black chairman of the Joint Chiefs. He served or commanded in more theaters of war than most of us could name, and in more high-level offices in Washington than most of us will ever know. He impressed just about everybody he ever served with or under.
He made mistakes. He acknowledged his mistakes. He had to live with his mistakes.
He was, in the classic sense, a great man: a man who was present at innumerable historic moments, who didn’t shrink from those moments, who understood his power and influence and gravitas and tried — not always successfully — to use them for good.
While Americans fight on the internet about Mr. Powell’s illness and vaccinations and whether he was really a rogue (for whatever we dislike about him) or really a hero (for whatever we like), we have to wonder: Is there room for great men and women in this country any longer? Great men and women who take great risks and do great good but also make great mistakes? Can no one command respect beyond our political battle lines? Must everybody be a rogue or a hero and nothing else? (In the end, of course, this means everyone is a rogue.)
Colin Powell, a flawed great man, died Monday at the age of 84. We should come together to mourn him or else we will soon be mourning for American greatness itself.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.