Sometimes all it takes are the worst possible images to hasten much needed reform of a broken policy. That seems to be the case with the treatment of Haitians who made it to the Rio Grande shoreline between Texas and Mexico where they were confronted by American border patrol officers on horses last week. The images, which looked like throwbacks to America’s antebellum and frontier pasts, were denounced on both sides of the political divide, but for very different reasons.

The consensus about the Biden administration’s handling of the migrants on the border, especially the hundreds of Haitians who were huddled in encampments under the bridge at Del Rio, has not been good. President Biden, like Presidents Obama, Bush and Clinton before him, has been stymied by the brokenness of the U.S. immigration system. President Trump exploited the chaos and added to it by dismantling any semblance of a workable asylum process and severely capping the number of foreigners who could legally immigrate to this country.

While vowing to come up with humane alternatives to the Trump administration’s policies, the Biden White House has continued many of its predecessor’s most egregious policies. There are reports that as many as a half dozen daily flights from the U.S. to Haiti were filled with migrants who didn’t have a chance to apply for asylum. This outraged many in the Democratic base who believed they were voting for fairer-minded policies when they backed Mr. Biden.

The horseback patrols have been halted, but the crisis at the border requires more than photo-op adjustments. The U.S. Congress has proven itself fundamentally unserious when it comes to addressing our immigration crisis, so it will be up to the Biden administration to take the initiative in the face of Republican intransigence. Immigration has to become more than an item on the vice president’s checklist. Finding a politically and morally compatible solution will require the creative engagement of the president and his entire cabinet.

You can tell a lot about a country by the way it treats the foreigners and strangers in its midst. This country has always attracted the most talented and ambitious migrants in the world as well as those fleeing catastrophe and oppression who simply yearn to breathe free. The only way America can truly live up to its creed is to be welcoming to both.