Adopting the stance of try, try again, the Federal Trade Commission is going after Facebook as a monopoly that illegally smothers competition.

Despite an earlier court ruling to the contrary, the FTC has filed litigation echoing arguments that have been heard before: Facebook is in violation of federal anti-trust rules.

The behemoth social media platform has grown even bigger over time with its acquisition of Instagram and WhatsApp, teasing regulators with its size, its command, its influence.

Evidence abounds that the social network should be broken up.

Advertise with us

The government contends — and, on its face, it would seem understandable — that Facebook’s waning popularity amidst other competitors more compatible for mobile devices prompted Facebook to acquire the more mobile-appropriate competition.

Facebook says its acquisition of Instagram and WhatsApp was good business and, more to the point, lawful.

And this would seem a perfect example of a company using its assets to acquire more assets in an effort to remain relevant and profitable. Put another way, it’s survival of the fittest in a capitalist system.

This would seem the American way, right? A company that is on the decline uses the revenue it already has accrued to buy other companies and beef up its bottom line.

At the same time and in tension, somewhat, with this principle is the historical consensus that monopolies are not a good thing. Too much power shouldn’t be concentrated in too big a single enterprise. Furthermore, when it comes to Facebook and social networking, the discussion has to turn to the idea of Big Tech and its control of communication — which should be of concern for its impact on the American value of free speech for all.

Advertise with us

The fact is, we are in territory not envisioned by those who crafted antitrust protections, let alone the First Amendment.

The power of technology giants like Facebook and Apple and Google and Amazon is nearly incomprehensible. The standards used to evaluate antitrust violations, which generally have been price impacts, aren’t as relevant when it comes to social media dominance. New metrics are needed in this discussion and those measures must look at impact beyond mere pricing: overall societal influence.

In its new legal complaint, the FTC is providing more details to support the government’s claims that Facebook has a monopoly in social networking. Can this battle be won in a court of law? Do legal precedent and current legislation protect America from the awesome power of tech companies? It is doubtful, but time will tell.

Meanwhile, federal lawmakers should undertake the difficult work of updating antitrust rules such that they acknowledge how the world has changed.