A comprehensive assessment of Pennsylvania’s juvenile justice system has yielded a thick report revealing that this so-called justice system is anything but just.

The findings: Most youth in the “system” have little or no history of delinquency; they haven’t committed the equivalent of a felony crime or a violent offense against a person; they do not present a high risk to re-offend.

Nonetheless, thousands of these juveniles — children — have been and are being denied their freedom.

A bipartisan interbranch task force found that more than half of the youths who have been adjudicated as “guilty” then remanded for “residential placement” — a nice way of saying they’ve been removed from their homes and their schools and their communities — are uprooted from their lives for what amounts to a misdemeanor offense. And most are sent to placement on their first adjudicated offense.

Advertise with us

Not only is this unfair, not only is it un-American, it is costly. In fact, such out-of-home placements can cost taxpayers up to $192,720 per youth per year.

And the task force has determined that the adjudications tilt disproportionately against those who are minorities and are poor.

Judge Kim Berkeley Clark, president judge of Allegheny County and chairwoman of the Pennsylvania Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission, made this observation about the “troubling data” that was revealed by the task force’s work: “... [C]hildren living in poverty and children of color are more likely to receive placement for their first offense.”

The report that was generated by the 30-member Pennsylvania Juvenile Justice Task Force sets forth 35 recommendations that, taken together, would potentially reduce out-of-home placement by 39% by 2026, which is estimated to free up more than $81 million in averted costs over five years.

This long-awaited and past-due report cannot be allowed to gather dust. Its findings demand immediate action and top-to-bottom reform.

Advertise with us

The goals should be to strengthen due process safeguards, including increased funding for juvenile defense and ensuring families understand their legal rights; to focus placement resources on young people who pose real threats and, for the majority, to utilize alternative community-based interventions; to cut fines and court fees and divert that money to restitution payments for victims; to narrow the criteria for trying in criminal court young people as adults — no more direct referrals by prosecutors to adult court without a hearing before a juvenile court judge; and to expand data reporting to the public about a system that is all but conducted behind closed doors.

Established in December 2019 by Gov. Tom Wolf, Supreme Court Justice Thomas Saylor and legislative leaders from both parties, the task force has produced data-driven assessments that should be the catalyst and foundation for immediate and sweeping legal and administrative changes to a juvenile justice system that is, currently, patently unjust.