Officials at Indiana University of Pennsylvania faced a dilemma in determining how to safely reopen the campus this fall to in-person teaching.
The state-owned school, one of 14 in the State System of Higher Education, believes it cannot legally require students to show proof of vaccination against the coronavirus. That, the State System believes, would require action from the state Legislature.
Any government mandate for proof of vaccination would constitute a government overreach.
IUP notified its more than 10,000 students that they will be required to wear masks at indoor settings this fall, including classrooms. While it’s understandable that school officials want to do everything possible to ensure a safe setting for learning, there is an alternative that should be considered: allow students who voluntarily show proof of vaccination to attend classes and events without a mask.
Emphasis: voluntarily. State government should not be in the business of requiring vaccination or proof of vaccination. But, a student can be given the choice of either wearing a mask or voluntarily showing evidence that he or she has been inoculated against the deadly virus.
In a statement to students, the university said it could not require or ask about vaccination status. “Because we won’t know the vaccination rate on campus — and we don’t have space inside our classrooms for social distancing — we are requiring masks to keep everyone safe,” the statement said.
That may indeed be the safest approach to stopping the spread of the coronavirus, but there is nothing to prohibit students from volunteering their vaccination status as a way to avoid continued mask use. It’s a step up from an honor-system approach that stores, businesses and churches have taken in recent weeks — those who are fully vaccinated are not required to wear a mask, while those who are not are asked to continue wearing one.
IUP officials should also continue efforts to entice students to roll up their sleeves for a vaccine, and to provide vaccination clinics on campus as means of increasing vaccination rates. But the requirement that everyone wear a mask indoors deserves an opt-out option.
More than 500 colleges and universities nationwide, mostly private schools, have chosen to require students to be vaccinated, while others are taking a less restrictive approach by encouraging vaccinations and even offering incentives — cash, lotteries for free tuition, college swag. State schools such as Penn State and the University of Pittsburgh — which are not state-owned — are among those encouraging, but not requiring, vaccinations.
Other schools in the State System have not announced plans similar to IUP’s, and each will make independent decisions on how to keep their campuses safe.
Gov. Tom Wolf has said he will veto any bill that would explicitly prohibit institutions of higher education in the state from requiring vaccinations.
IUP’s mask mandate is almost certain to get pushback from students who have been fully vaccinated. The school should allow those who volunteer their vaccination status to skip the mask.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.