When school board members passed the new protocol on a 7-2 vote in late 2017, Pittsburgh Public Schools trumpeted the news that it was the first school system in Pennsylvania to ban out-of-school suspension for the district’s youngest students.
The ban applied to children in preschool through second grade and covered behaviors classified as nonviolent infractions such as tardy arrivals, violations of dress code or disrupting class.
It was akin to proudly announcing “I’ve stopped beating my spouse!” or “I’m no longer cheating on my taxes!”
That any school system would have been suspending a child barely out of diapers for any nonviolent infraction is preposterous.
Now, the district is weighing the expanding of the ban to children in third, fourth and fifth grades. Reminder: We’re talking about kids who (at the oldest) have barely hit the double-digits in terms of age.
The question shouldn’t be whether to extend the out-of-school suspension ban for nonviolent infractions to children ages 10 (or thereabouts) and younger. The question should be why would young children ever be subjected to out-of-school suspension for nonviolent behavior in the first place?
PPS recently commissioned a study of the K-2 suspension ban which began in fall 2018 and that study disclosed a few matters of concern. First, according to the statistics, it appears some K-2 students still were given out-of-school suspensions for behavior in the category of nonviolent, contrary to the policy. Second, it could be that the statistics were flawed and reflected errors in the categorizing of the behavior. (Really?) Third, those doing the study couldn’t get staff to fully participate in the information gathering process. (Why and who actually is in charge?)
Whether the study was flawed and, if so, why is not nearly as important as the next consideration: extending the ban on out-of-school suspension for nonviolent behavior. It should be done now. It should have been done in 2017 when advocates and parents asked for it.
There’s a trove of research showing the ineffectiveness — the actual deleterious impact — of out-of-school suspension on students. High numbers of missed school days are connected to a greater likelihood of academic struggle which connects to higher drop-out rates which smooths the school-to-prison pipeline.
There is no question that teachers and administrators need to have disciplinary tools in hand to deal with unruly students. And the reality of in-school violence cannot be ignored. But there are better ways to make schools safe and well-ordered than barring admission to young children, especially when the gates are being lowered for behavior that amounts to not obeying the rules or behavior such as repeated late arrival that really is the fault of a parent and not a child who may not even be able to tell time.
Removing young children from school is not a good answer to the problem of bad behavior among young students, though it may be the easiest one. In fact, in 2013, a study on behalf of the ACLU listed PPS among the top 10 in the state with the highest suspension rates. And it found that Black students in Pennsylvania were five times more likely than white students to be suspended.
Children who have problems with tardiness, with disruptive behavior, with rule-following in general need extra help, not a withdrawal of help. Alternatives must be considered that key on restorative justice, mental health support, some deeper probing into any underlying problems that evidence themselves in “bad” behavior.
PPS is about to get an infusion of federal money. Some of it should be spent to set up systems that ensure all children are in school every day of the school year and that those children who are troubled receive help. More cannot be pushed onto the shoulders of teachers who already buckle under the weight of awesome responsibility and expectation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.