Five years ago, President Barack Obama nominated for the Supreme Court a moderate jurist who had prosecuted the nation’s worst case of domestic terrorism.

His name was Merrick Garland.

He was chief judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia — highly qualified, highly respected, and a judge neither left nor right.

He should have been confirmed.

Advertise with us

Instead, the Republican leadership of the U.S. Senate buried his nomination on the dubious constitutional ground that the man who nominated him (President Obama) was a lame duck. Mr. Obama had almost 10 months to go in his second term.

Judge Garland did not even get a hearing. And that was an insult, not only to him, and President Obama, but to the democratic process and the traditions of the Senate.

The (mostly) same Senate Republicans, and the same Senate Republican leader, saw nothing amiss with holding hearings for a Supreme Court nominee by a president with a little less than four months to go in his term. That president was Donald Trump and the nominee was Amy Coney Barrett.

The Constitution says nothing about limiting a president’s right to nominate judges based on time remaining in office.

The interesting thing is that out of a totally compromised, indeed corrupted, political process we could get an uncommonly thoughtful justice — Ms. Barrett — and, now, a potentially great attorney general — Mr. Garland.

Advertise with us

For the same spurned and disrespected Merrick Garland has been nominated to be attorney general by President Joseph R. Biden.

Last week, Mr. Garland finally got a hearing from the Senate Judiciary Committee.

The president is not just squaring the circle and delivering an ironic ending to an unfair past result. He is tapping a fine civil servant to use, as Mr. Garland said, all of his skills, at the peak of his powers, for the greater good.

The Justice Department needs to be rebuilt and its morale restored.

Another irony: Just as Amy Coney Barrett, in her confirmation hearings, tamed some yahoos and demagogues on the Senate Judiciary committee — with her intellect, honesty and simple decency — Merrick Garland did the same. He did so with the same three qualities.

Advertise with us

Confirmation hearings render verbal contracts, and Judge Garland made some promises. He said he would find and prosecute the Capitol rioters; he would target white supremacy and domestic terror as a priority; he would not defund police; he explained systemic bias to a couple of Senate louts.

As a prosecutor, Mr. Garland sought the death penalty for Timothy McVeigh, perpetrator of the Oklahoma City bombings in 1995. He now doubts it can be administered fairly and will probably recommend a moratorium on it.

Finally, he explained why an heir of Holocaust survivors wants to give back. For he is giving up a lifetime appointment as a federal judge to take a tough job that, at best, will likely last no more than four years. This country protected us, he said, in a choked voice.

Like Justice Barrett, this is a jurist of intellect and soul.

Mr. Garland, summing up, said justice should be blind, but not heartless — a pretty sound mantra.

Advertise with us

Every once in a while, our country is treated to real substance in a congressional hearing.

Every once in a while, justice prevails and a good man, or woman, gets his day.

President Biden has nominated some top-notch people for his Cabinet (also some real duds). Janet Yellen, at Treasury, having been head of the Federal Reserve and the president’s Council of Economic Advisers, is almost overqualified. She could be the most notable Treasury secretary since Hamilton. The same is true of William Burns at the CIA. He is a brilliant and veteran diplomat.

It is inspiring to see qualification and integrity in Cabinet nominees. No nominee is more inspiring than Merrick Garland.