Much of art history is filled with tales of wealthy individuals supporting artists. A version of this patronage system continues even today, with many arts organizations tending to rely on a small pool of donors to pay for significant portions of their budgets.
These generous figures are key players in the art world, as their munificence often entitles them to help chart the course of such organizations. However, this style of fundraising and budgeting contributes to the idea that the fine arts especially are made for society’s elites.
New data reveals that COVID-19 is democratizing the playing field. A report by the data firm TRG shows that while there was a dip in charitable donations to arts organizations during 2020 of about 13%, about 15% more people donated last year than in previous years.
In other words, more people gave in smaller amounts last year. This is welcome news.
While organizations often chase those white-whale high-dollar gifts, such financial aid often engenders with a sense of ownership or even comes with strings attached. This is not to criticize those who give in large amounts or to chastise organizations for accepting them, of course — such benefactors are to be commended, as their gifts have long resulted in creations of great beauty. However, this reliance on large donations has its drawbacks.
If such individuals decide to pull their support or if they pass away, the arts group is left holding the bag and has to scramble to replace that income. This sets up an incentive to constantly seek out large donations rather than focusing on a broader pitch to the public.
And at some organizations, such large gifts have resulted in major donors having input over the artistic product, or in troubling behavior being tolerated behind the scenes more indulgently than it should be.
Unlike in Europe, American arts organizations rely far more heavily on private support rather than state sponsorship. It is up to the organizations to demonstrate their community value above and beyond the price of a ticket, and this idea of “cultural relevance” has been discussed ad nauseum by arts groups in recent decades.
In 2020, the numbers indicate they were successful in convincing people that they matter.
Now, pluralities of gifts are becoming more significant than a single large gift or two, as nearly 75% of American arts organizations saw increases in the number of donors. These new donors, while their gifts may be smaller, are also becoming stakeholders in these organizations. Arts organizations would be wise to invite those with talent and interest to participate in board and committee functions, assignments often reserved for the uber-wealthy who meet a certain threshold of giving.
As the TRG report notes, the increased numbers did not reach the same level of giving as in previous years, but once COVID-19 restrictions are lifted, arts fundraisers should push to make up the difference with additional donations, not by returning to a pattern of seeking out large gifts. In the years to come, a constant churn of numerous small donations will be far more sustainable than relying on a few individuals for the bulk of the budget deficits.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.