For as much pride as Pittsburgh has in its three rivers, they remain remarkably filthy.
Experts have consistently revised estimates upward for exactly how much sewage-laced stormwater runs into the rivers, and current best guesses suggest it’s about 15 billion gallons each year. Due to increased rainfall in the region, that number will likely continue to swell.
Local authorities consistently harp on the importance of solving the sewage overflow issues but have remained stuck in the muck for decades.
The regional authority, the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority (Alcosan), has a court-mandated $2 billion, Environmental Protection Agency-approved plan to reduce sewage runoff by 2036 using a mixture of green infrastructure, such as rehabilitating lakes and creating wetlands to hold and redirect stormwater from shared pipes, as well as gray infrastructure, such as the construction of additional concrete piping and storage tunnels.
But Alcosan isn’t directly responsible for local municipal wastewater infrastructure. In Pittsburgh, that authority lies primarily with the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority.
On Oct. 28, the PWSA, along with Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto, announced that it is seeking proposals for a comprehensive stormwater master plan for Pittsburgh. The announcement follows on the heels of a Rand Corp. study that concludes that increasing rainfall in the area could exacerbate storm and sewage overflows in the Negley Run watershed, which currently spits an estimated 986 million gallons of sewer and stormwater overflow a year into the Allegheny River.
But here’s the real takeaway from the study’s proposed solutions: Using a combination of gray and green alternatives would divert only up to 40% of overflow at best.
True, green solutions have added benefits such as reducing flooding and improving air quality. And in some cases, they are significantly more cost-effective in combination with gray solutions than gray solutions alone.
But a maximum of a 40% reduction is nowhere near enough. The Rand Corp. study estimates that the Negley Run watershed alone could top 2 billion gallons of overflow a year if rain increases sufficiently.
This is a start, but it isn’t a realistic solution.
Pittsburgh has been exploring green options at least since 2012, and prevailing wisdom indicates that any solution will be a combination of green and gray projects. However, the open call for proposals reveals that the process remains bogged down in hypotheticals and pie-in-the-sky solutions.
Given that the EPA threatened the region with sanctions for violating the 1972 Clean Water Act as far back as 1997, Alcosan’s molasses-like movement to develop a coherent plan and stick to it is sheer delinquency. The PWSA seems to be following in these footsteps.
Controlling sewage overflow remains one of the greatest challenges to the city’s reputation and quality of life. Green projects will be an essential component of any master plan, but they shouldn’t come at the expense of potentially more effective solutions. Leaders should not continue flushing time down the drain in pursuit of perfect solutions.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.