Pittsburgh area school districts are bringing students back to in-person instruction, even as some schools temporarily close down due to coronavirus cases.
Seven months into the pandemic, schools are demonstrating more nimbleness in their virus responses and prioritizing the well-being of students and teachers alike. Research has indicated time and again, however, that moving students back into a physical learning environment is crucial for their development.
Looking to the data, transmission rates of the virus at in-person school districts around the country have been exceptionally low, well below 0.2% in many cases.
This flies in the face of predictions that schools would be hotbeds for spreading COVID-19.
Locally, Fox Chapel Area has announced that it will bring kindergarten through fifth graders back for face-to-face instruction in November, while older students will continue using the hybrid model. Bethel Park hopes to bring students back for five-day-per-week learning by mid-November as well. Pittsburgh Public Schools, currently online only, hopes to launch a hybrid model in November.
On the other end of this spectrum, Derry Area School District and Norwin School District have both closed down school buildings after COVID-19 cases were discovered in the student body.
Transmission isn’t at zero, of course, and for some, even an infinitesimally small chance of illness or death is too great to risk reopening. But as with lockdown measures, it’s high time for leaders to look to actual data over projections as they simply don’t align.
Balancing risk is part of life. The learning and developmental issues that arise from keeping students at home are significant and, in some cases, severe. The stress on parents shouldn’t be minimized, either.
Even when schools open, parents retain the right to keep their children at home for online learning if they believe the virus presents too great a threat.
This will not be an easy decision, for schools or families alike. But recognizing that each situation is unique and that a school’s circumstances can change on a dime is certainly a step in the right direction. Opening up as safely as possible and allowing families to opt in or out is another positive step, as is looking to data and taking non-coronavirus factors into the risk equation as well.
Area school districts should be commended for doing the best they can in a difficult situation to look after the developmental and physical health of their staff and students. No one wants to see anyone seriously impacted by the virus, but there must be a reckoning with the other factors at play.
Those that can begin to open up should continue doing so.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.