Federal prosecution of protesters already facing criminal allegations in the state court system is both a redundant waste of taxpayer money and a backhanded slap in the face of Lady Justice.
Yet these dual and simultaneous prosecutions are happening in jurisdictions across our nation, including in our own backyard.
Some Allegheny County protesters who already have been charged with crimes stemming from racial justice demonstrations now are facing federal charges stemming from the same underlying incidents.
Though this indecipherable stratagem defies logic, it does not deny the defendants’ constitutional rights. It does, however, deserve outcry from anyone interested in due process and cohesion to the spirit of double jeopardy — a legal tenet that prohibits the accused from facing trial twice for the same alleged crime.
The workaround in these cases of dual prosecution is the fact of dual sovereignty, meaning that the federal court system and the state court system are entirely distinct enterprises. Double jeopardy cannot be applied.
So be it. But good sense can and should be applied in these cases, which can be adequately handled by the state courts.
Such is not and has not always been the case at other times and in other places. Throughout American history, since the 1800s, federal prosecutors have stepped in to deliver justice when the state courts have failed due to either real or perceived conflicts of interest. When local courts in the South staged sham prosecutions of defendants accused of civil rights violations — prosecutions that predictably ended (or would have ended) with acquittals despite overwhelming evidence of guilt — the feds stepped in to make things right. And there have been more recent cases, including a police assault on Rodney King in 1991 in California. Police officers were acquitted of state criminal allegations then were indicted and convicted in federal court for civil rights violations. Justice prevailed.
In this place and in this time, justice is in the rearview mirror as dual prosecutions are proceeding simultaneously. The Allegheny County district attorney’s office is as perplexed as the public should be. A spokesman issued a statement: “It remains unclear why the federal government chose to charge these cases only after state charges had already been filed. We will be proceeding with these prosecutions until disposition of the state charges.”
The U.S. Department of Justice clearly has sent a message to its U.S. attorneys to make the point that criminal conduct during protests won’t be tolerated. That’s valid. But the point already has been made and due process is, in fact, proceeding. Federal involvement is an unnecessary stretch.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.