Imagine starting a debate society from scratch. What would its guiding principles be? The fair exchange of ideas. The freedom to address controversial issues. A space dedicated to civil disagreement.

These are all worthy and necessary objectives, but what about prioritizing the psychological comfort of its members? This principle would in fact subvert all the others and eventually render the society impotent.

This attitude has prevailed at Trinity College Dublin’s Historical Society, the Hist, the oldest student organization in the world, with roots dating back to 1747 when philosopher Edmund Burke founded the club. The society holds weekly debates and hosts high-profile speakers. But this year’s guest speaker, renowned author and evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins, has been disinvited by the Hist because of comments he made about Islam and sexual assault.

Mr. Dawkins apparently would have remained in good stead with the student group if his incessant criticism of religion were restricted to Christianity; however, former tweets reveal that he has broken a major taboo. He had the temerity to criticize Islam. Revealing its bigotry of low expectations, the Hist believes Muslims are incapable of, or should be shielded from, hearing such criticism. Anti-Christianity is fine. Anti-Islam is not.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dawkins has described Islam as “the greatest force for evil in the world today,” and referred to the “pernicious influence” of Islamic faith schools. Whether members of the Hist agree or disagree with this sentiment, whether they think it is absurd or gratuitous, what good does it do them if they are shielded from hearing it? That is what the debate stage is for, to determine the cogency of arguments.

Wading into the minefield of sexual assault, Mr. Dawkins suggested that getting so drunk that you are unable to remember being assaulted might make it slightly difficult to prosecute. Is this view so dangerous that Hist students must be protected from it?

Mr. Dawkins was canceled because, as auditor of the Hist Brid O’Donnell said, “We value our members’ comfort above all else.” A history society at a university that has a long, proud intellectual tradition should find such silencing of ideas anathema. Freedom from discomfort stifles debate and potential understanding. Hearing things you disagree with is a form of education.

Mr. Dawkins managed to achieve what former speakers of the Hist, including Winston Churchill, Samuel Beckett and even Oscar Wilde were unable to do: be so unsettling to students that they must be canceled.