What’s in a veto?
Sometimes, it’s nothing other than a principled stand, as on Monday when Gov. Tom Wolf vetoed a state House bill that would have allowed individual schools to decide how many spectators could attend sports games this fall.
Because the bill passed both the House and Senate with a two-thirds majority, the veto is likely a temporary block only. If it passes with such a strong majority a second time, it’ll become law, and legislators are champing at the bit to hold an override vote quickly.
Mr. Wolf is continuing to insist that the 250-person cap on outdoor gatherings provides a measure of safety against catching COVID-19, even after a federal judge ruled that such broad limitations are unconstitutional, no matter how well intentioned. (The governor is appealing that decision.)
No one is arguing that congregating doesn’t increase people’s chances of catching the virus — this is obvious — but the double standard between sporting events and, say, continued protests is infuriating.
After all, this is the same administration that quietly allowed a 20,000-person car show to take place in Carlisle.
How arbitrary these decisions seem.
Schools should be able to make the decision whether to host spectators or not based on their seating capacity and ability to enforce health guidelines and recommendations like masking and social distancing.
The Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association earlier determined that individual school districts could decide for themselves whether to play sports this fall. School administrators are not health experts, but this is a question of whether they can follow state guidelines, not reinvent the pandemic-prevention wheel.
The same responsibility should fall to schools in the decision about whether to allow people to watch games live.
Mr. Wolf’s aim is noble, but his methods are unnecessarily authoritarian.
When he claims that “I’m always amazed at politicians thinking that they can somehow wave a magic wand and suspend reality,” this is a distraction from the overall question here: Can schools be trusted to act in the best interests of their students and potential spectators, or do they need a nanny state imposing rules and restrictions from on high?
And can spectators be trusted to look after their own health and immediate social and familial circles?
Citizens are better equipped to make decisions regarding their own health than they were six months ago. The veto is a continued attempt to maintain a degree of control that the governor should not possess this far removed from the initial panic over the pandemic.
The state is by no means out of the woods, but if masking and social distancing are effective deterrents to spreading COVID-19 then it’s time to rely on this and not arbitrary event caps. Schools should decide for themselves what capacity they can accept.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.