Concerned that Gov. Tom Wolf is acting more like a king than a governor in exercising his emergency powers, the GOP-controlled state Legislature is trying to limit his powers by amending the state constitution.
However, in doing so, the Legislature is guilty of the same overreach of which Mr. Wolf is accused.
Mr. Wolf initially issued a 90-day emergency powers declaration in March when the first coronavirus cases were being reported in Pennsylvania. He then reissued the declaration in June. The declaration does give the governor broad powers, and Mr. Wolf used it to close schools and businesses and force people to stay in their homes.
Some Republicans contended that the governor went too far and then moved too slowly in reopening the state, causing much unnecessary pain and suffering for residents and businesses. They also maintained that the governor’s distinction between essential and nonessential was confusing and arbitrary.
Others have said Mr. Wolf’s application of shutdowns and reopenings has been unbalanced, and they have a point. Restaurant owners, for example, have whiplash.
So, GOP lawmakers sent several bills to Mr. Wolf that would loosen the restrictions, but he vetoed them. Republicans sued to end his emergency order, but the state Supreme Court rejected their arguments and sided with the governor.
Republicans then came up with a way to get around Mr. Wolf. They passed an amendment to the state constitution that would permit the governor to issue an emergency declaration for 21 days and then allow the Legislature to vote by a simple majority on whether it could be extended. The bill will have to be approved again next year before it can be put on the ballot for a referendum, but that could happen in time for the primary election next spring.
By limiting the declaration to 21 days and allowing the Legislature to overturn it by a simple majority vote, Republicans have turned this into a bitterly partisan issue when or if it shows up on the ballot.
To be sure, there should be some limits to any governor’s power. However, only allowing such declarations to exist for 21 days is nonsense. Ninety days is a much better time frame for governors to deal with emergencies.
Also, allowing a simple majority to overrule a governor would create massive confusion and uncertainty. Like it or not, there has to be someone in charge during an emergency. A two-thirds vote to overrule would be much better, giving lawmakers some say in the governor’s actions but not totally taking away his power.
The bottom line is that neither the Legislature nor the governor has performed wisely or consistently during the pandemic. There does not seem to be an adult in the house.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.