U.S. military operations against the Islamic militant group al-Shabab have escalated in recent years, resulting in more and more airstrikes being launched in Somalia and other East African nations. But critics allege that the U.S. government has not properly accounted for the civilian victims of these strikes, dodging a policy to pay restitution to the families of those unjustly injured or killed. It is past time that victims receive reparation for the wrong enacted upon them.

In a letter to Gen. Stephen J. Townsend, commander of United States Africa Command (also known as AFRICOM), a group of Democratic lawmakers led by Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., called for “increased transparency and public accountability of civilian casualties” as the air war continues.

The letter comes on the heels of an increasingly rare admission from the government that one of its strikes killed civilians; in April, AFRICOM admitted that two civilians were killed and three more were injured in a 2019 airstrike.

But that admission still falls far short of the devastation alleged by nongovernmental organizations. Amnesty International analyzed nine airstrikes between 2017 and 2019, identifying 21 civilians killed and 11 more injured. The research group Airwars has tracked strikes back to 2007 and estimates deaths to be as high as 142. Both organizations agree that the U.S. has not accurately assessed the death toll.

Advertise with us

Accurate civilian death counts are not only important for properly assessing the devastation for a conflict, but also for determining “condolence payments,” per a new U.S. policy. As established by Section 936 of the 2019 National Defense Authorization Act, the Department of Defense must appoint a senior civilian official who must ensure that the DOD establishes standards and processes for acknowledging responsibility for civilian casualties and offering payments to victims and their families.

Such payments have occurred in the past, largely in secret, but Section 936 sought to formalize the process.

While noble in intent, this policy incentivizes dubious counting techniques. While it is not publicly known why the DOD acknowledged two civilian deaths among dozens of alleged killings, it is known that the U.S. government has manipulated operational definitions to protect its interests. Most notably, the government has often counted any military-age male it kills as an “enemy combatant” until it is proved otherwise.

Ms. Omar and her colleagues should push for the Pentagon to proactively engage with another of its mandates under Section 936: work with NGOs to create a more public process for assessing claims of civilian casualties.

It is important the violence toward civilians receives acknowledgment and institutional attention within the United States. American military operations have wrought unjust pain and suffering on people not just in East Africa, but in dozens of countries throughout the world.

Victims unlawfully harmed by state action have a right to redress, and acknowledgment of their misery through financial compensation would be an important step toward greater accountability for a U.S. military program that has too often operated with impunity.