Years of controversy surrounding government surveillance programs have inspired federal agencies to outsource their spy programs, paying third-party vendors millions for enormous troves of sensitive data. Congress should step in and put an end to this dubious practice.
Public outcry over warrantless surveillance programs culminated in the 2018 landmark Supreme Court case Carpenter v. United States. The court ruled that cellphone location data is a specially protected class of information because of how much it reveals about Americans. The court also decided that law enforcement could no longer obtain location data directly from cellphone providers without judicial approval.
But government lawyers identified a workaround — agencies could buy data from marketing firms and other commercial surveillance companies that accumulate mass amounts of data, typically to be sold to advertisers, and not be in violation of the Carpenter ruling.
This data runs the gamut from social media post analysis to real-time location information.
A number of federal agencies, including Customs and Border Protection and Immigration and Customs Enforcement, have already exploited this system, spending millions on data to track phones traveling across American borders.
The FBI has also expanded its third-party contracts, partnering with companies like Dataminr and Venntel to monitor social media and collect cellphone location data. Venntel, which has also partnered with the Department of Homeland Security and the IRS, is the subject of a recently opened investigation by the U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Reform, which has requested information about how the company collects and sells data to government agencies.
But Congress should expand the scope of its inquiry, taking more direct aim at the government’s exploitation of the third-party loophole. “The government is using its checkbook to get around Carpenter,” said Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., a frequent critic of government surveillance overreach. “Americans won’t stand for that kind of loophole when it comes to our Fourth Amendment rights.”
Lawmakers must hold the federal government accountable, particularly when their actions infringe upon Americans’ civil liberties. These agencies must not be allowed to work around important privacy protections. Congress must improve its oversight and work to close the loopholes in the Carpenter decision.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.