Richard Grenell said some flippant, unserious and unkind things in his time as ambassador to Germany. He made decisions that some say undermined the intelligence community and politicized it as acting director of national intelligence. He is addicted to Twitter, much like his former boss, President Donald Trump.

Mr. Grenell has been accused of encouraging support for conservative and right politicians and parties in Europe and making sexist comments about women such as commentators Rachel Maddow and Katy Tur.

None of that is a good enough reason for Carnegie Mellon University to withdraw his selection as a senior fellow.

First, the CMU administration has the right to appoint him and no one not in the administration has the right to negate his appointment because he or she is upset by something Mr. Grenell said.

Advertise with us

Second, a university is, or should be, a bastion of free speech and thought and a haven for independent thinkers, even — especially — if they offend.

The response to controversial statements should be debate, discussion and counter arguments — not attempts to silence opponents. This is especially true at a university.

About 260 faculty and staff at CMU signed a letter calling for the school to withdraw its selection of Mr. Grenell to a one-year appointment as a senior fellow in the school’s Institute of Politics and Strategy.

They claim the appointment damages CMU’s academic integrity and challenge whether the institute’s director had the authority to make the decision.

It’s difficult to see how the school’s academic integrity could be damaged by hearing a voice — unpopular though it may be with many faculty, staff and students — that brings a viewpoint not often heard on the CMU campus.

Advertise with us

Mr. Grenell certainly has abundant experience at some of the highest levels of government. In addition to his roles as ambassador to Germany and acting director of national intelligence, he also served in the George W. Bush administration and was a U.S. spokesman at the United Nations. He was the nation’s first openly gay member of a president’s cabinet and has been a conservative political commentator.

If we were talking about a fellowship for a former U.S. Ambassador to Germany who served under President Barack Obama, there would be no controversy, only welcome.

Mr. Grenell’s critics say he was not a very good ambassador because he was highly undiplomatic and way too political. But that does not relate to CMU’s right to hire him or the different perspective he would bring to campus.

Why not hear Mr. Grenell? Freedom of speech depends on listening to challenging viewpoints, not shutting them down. That is the confident promise of our republic.