Somewhere, Joseph Stalin is smiling. And Jefferson Davis is dancing on Grant’s tomb.
When we destroy and deny history, when we fail to even attempt to understand historical context, the absurdity of the toppling of a statue of Ulysses S. Grant in San Francisco makes perfect sense.
And ignorance becomes the new normal.
So why was Grant’s statue a target?
Well, he was an imperfect man who lived in an imperfect time. It was a time very different in its imperfections, its sins and deceits, than our own.
Grant was a rough-and-tough fellow who fought and won a bloody, merciless civil war. He had views on race that were unenlightened by today’s standards.
He drank a lot.
Grant also did, in fact, once own a slave, briefly. He freed the man at the beginning of the Civil War.
But historic truth is complicated, like most truth. Here is some complicated historic truth about Grant: Until Lyndon B. Johnson, no U.S. president did more to use the power of the federal government to guarantee the rights of African Americans than Grant.
Grant’s military genius, and his partnership with Abraham Lincoln, ended slavery in the United States.
Grant was a passionate Reconstructionist, facing down the Ku Klux Klan throughout the South and using federal troops, when necessary, to do so.
Grant was a thinking person and ultimately evolved and fiercely opposed slavery.
He was a good president, a great general and a fine writer (memoirist and historian, as it happens). He deserves to be remembered.
The people who tore down his statue, the culprits in this act of destruction and desecration, know little of all that and understand less. For history is not a comic book or a pep rally. History is tragic because the human experience is.
The San Francisco Jacobins also showed their lack of empathy — the ability to understand people in the context of their lives and times.
Historical monuments don’t equal history or even teach all of it. But they are a part of history and a part of how history can live and inform us as we grow and strive to perfect our union.
The whole statue-toppling craze shows how out of touch we are in this nation today with our past, and how poorly we preserve and teach history, both in civil society and in schools.
One way that Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin controlled national memory was to rewrite history. He simply eliminated his enemies, perceived and real, from the history books.
He often also eliminated their lives. The slope is slippery.
To Stalin, anyone who stepped out of his conception of the past deserved obliteration. Stalin knew that history had power, so he had to control it.
So it was chilling when a corporate CEO said recently about “canceling” First Amendment rights: The past is irrelevant. Only today matters.
That is the totalitarian echo.
At least Stalin understood what he was doing. Today’s censors live in an intellectual vacuum.
History is not only complicated; it is often ugly. That is because of the “crooked timber of humanity” and the everlasting folly of the powerful.
And we all remain products of our times — steeped in the illusions of our times.
A few of us do better at seeing around the corner. But no one can see the future as clearly as the past. Looking backward we always have a wider lens, though always with various prisms.
Jefferson Davis, though, would be thrilled by the attacks on Grant. Advocates for the myths of the Confederacy long attempted to rewrite history and portray the North and its leaders as cynical pillagers. The “lost cause” theory of the Civil War depended on a completely one-sided view of history.
Those who tear down monuments also have a one-sided view. They see only us and them. And most know almost nothing of what has gone before, only the vapid, sophomoric and narcissistic now.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.