Pennsylvania has long had a weirdly dysfunctional relationship with alcohol. The state controls the sale of hard liquor — or “spirits” — and wine through the state-run liquor stores. Beer is sold separately through private distributorships and up until recently had to be purchased by the case.
In recent years, rules have been loosened to allow for limited sales of beer and wine in some — but not all — supermarkets and convenience stores. There are even more rules and exceptions for microbreweries, small distilleries and local wineries.
It’s confusing and inconsistent enough that even lifelong residents of the state aren’t sure what rules apply to what purchases or establishments.
Even more inconsistency — coupled with massive inconvenience — has been the rule since Gov. Tom Wolf ordered state liquor stores closed last month because of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Liquor stores were closed, but beer distributors could remain open because they, oddly enough, were deemed “life-sustaining” businesses.
Attempts at online liquor purchases through the state produced little more than frustration for most consumers who usually were unable to connect to the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board’s completely overwhelmed website. That sent customers scurrying across the border to neighboring states where alcohol can be purchased in more locations and with fewer restrictions.
But Pennsylvania residents soon held the distinction of being barred from purchasing alcohol in two states — West Virginia and Ohio — after governors shut down liquor sales to the horde of out-of-state customers.
So it was a relief to hear some measure of common sense had prevailed when Mr. Wolf announced on April 20 that the state was easing up on the restrictions for liquor purchases. The state opened 176 of its stores last week for call-in ordering and purchasing, coupled with curbside pickup. That will expand starting Monday to 565 of the nearly 600 stores statewide.
The move will allow the employees at the state-run liquor stores to return to work to take and fill orders, while still maintaining social distancing and observing health guidelines. Consumers can place orders over the phone — during limited hours — pay with a credit card and pick up their purchases without having to enter a store.
You’d think a state that does a booming business in alcohol would have worked to come up with a way to continue sales efforts from the outset of the shutdown. In the last fiscal year, the PLCB reported record sales and net income. Sales totaled $2.67 billion, an increase of $75.2 million from a year earlier, while net income was $191 million, an increase of 20%.
The phone ordering and curbside pickup still don’t offer the same convenience of neighboring states where customers often can make purchases in grocery stores, but it’s better than the total shutdown previously in place. One can only hope the recent events might lead lawmakers to finally rethink the way Pennsylvania handles liquor sales.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.