The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has proposed that manufacturers and physicians ensure women seeking breast implants know about all the risks involved. But the FDA’s pending rule should be stronger, requiring plainer view of what and how things could go wrong.

The agency announced recently a proposed rule that recommends manufacturers include a warning box on each breast implant package. The agency also recommends patients complete a checklist to make sure they understand all the possible side effects of the implants, such as scarring, pain, rupture and even a rare form of cancer.

A recommendation, though, isn’t good enough. It should be a requirement.

The history of breast implants has generated enough evidence for concern to warrant clear, unambiguous, and detailed information. Women considering breast implants, whether for breast augmentation or following surgery, must be fully advised of the negative experiences some women have had and the necessity for monitoring and even possible replacement.

Advertise with us

The pending regulation is in a public comment period through late December on the Federal Register. The document is on the FDA’s website as No. 84 FR 57028.

Implants have a silicone outer shell and are filled with either saline or silicone. Each year, about 300,000 patients get implants for breast augmentation, while about 100,000 are implanted following cancer surgery.

The agency wants implant manufacturers to explain that breast implants often require repeat surgeries. They should not be considered lifelong devices. About one in five women who get implants for cosmetic reasons need to have them removed within eight to 10 years, the FDA said.

Plastic surgeons point out that the incidence of related health problems is small, and a warning would not be of much help for that reason.

The FDA agrees that implants are essentially safe. Nonetheless, full disclosure of possible complications should be made. There is anecdotal evidence of women blaming implants for health problems including rheumatoid arthritis, chronic fatigue, and muscle pain.

Information is essential. Information is power.