Katie Hill has been forced by her party to resign her seat in the U.S. House of Representatives. She is being punished for her own poor judgment and the viciousness of an ex-husband.
The former Democratic congresswoman from California, once a rising star, was accused of carrying on a sexual relationship with a House staffer, which is against House rules. She denies this but says she did have such a relationship with a campaign staffer, which is not against House rules.
In addition, naked pictures of Ms. Hill surfaced and were widely circulated by social media and by some allegedly legitimate news organizations.
In a culture in which privacy is virtually gone and voyeurism a significant part of how we relate to each other, Ms. Hill became a commodity, and a convenient foil for sanctimonious hypocrites. Some of the same people who exploited and degraded Ms. Hill had the chutzpah to deplore her tattoo!
Taking naked selfies is never a great idea, especially if you are in politics.
But here’s the thing. It was apparently a vengeful ex-husband who released the pictures. Not Ms. Hill. Who is questioning his judgment and ethics? Where is his punishment?
Is each individual member of the U.S. House prepared for scrutiny of every aspect of his or her private life, including every aspect of his or her sex life?
Is each American?
If every member of Congress who became involved with a staff member — many, many congressmen and senators have married current and ex-staffers — were expelled from the House and Senate, Capitol Hill would be a very lonely place, both back in the day and today.
And women in politics, or thinking about politics, are right to wonder how a Bill Clinton or Donald Trump gets a full pass for his libido while Ms. Hill is held to some sort of higher standard that cannot be articulated, let alone met.
We live in a time when what ought to be bad jokes become reality. Members of Congress as arbiters of sexual morality? One would have thought they would be the last sociological subset to cast stones.
But then politicians do lead the nation in shamelessness and lack of self-awareness.
Ms. Hill obviously had a messy private life. So do many in our society, and our workplaces, and our families. So what? Unless there was coercion involved, Ms. Hill’s private life should have remained private. And if it really impinged on her ability to represent her constituents at some point, they, the voters, should have been the ones to decide whether she remained in the House or was tossed out.
This was not a case of applying #MeToo principles — assuming we are all clear on what they are — to a woman. This was purely a human sacrifice to a recent idol.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.