President Donald Trump won the presidency in part on his promise to end the United States’ involvement in “endless wars.” After nearly two decades of continuous fighting throughout the Middle East, Americans are tired. The country has paid dearly for these wars, in both blood and treasure, and, he is right, it is time for them to stop.

But extracting the U.S. from these conflicts was never going to be simple and Mr. Trump’s unilateral decision to withdraw about 1,000 troops from northern Syria, has left America’s Kurdish allies totally vulnerable to attack, indeed to wholesale slaughter.

The Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces have been an invaluable ally in the war against the Islamic State. The SDF led a number of key offensives, culminating in the seizure of the last of IS’ territory in Syria this past March. These efforts devastated IS’ control of the region and spared the lives of American soldiers in the process.

In fact, the SDF’s strength and operational savvy minimized the United States’ overall entanglement in the region. Beyond its supply of training and arms, the U.S. acted primarily as a barrier between the Kurds and their enemies, including Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad and the Turkish military, who have made repeated efforts to oppress and exterminate the Kurds.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Trump, in his effort to withdraw the U.S. from Syria, has left the SDF exposed to a Turkish assault. The consequences have been devastating: Turkey launched an offensive and, before a temporary cease-fire was put in place on Oct. 17, thousands of civilians were displaced and hundreds were killed. The SDF reported that nearly 750 IS detainees escaped after a Turkish airstrike. The U.N. has announced it is investigating Turkey for the alleged use of the chemical weapon white phosphorus.

Again, Mr. Trump is right in concept. Americans are wary of nation building in places nations never get built. What America mother wants to send her son or daughter to fight in Syria, for the Kurds or anyone else? Mr. Trump should have created aprocess of withdrawl. He should have searched for alternatives, consulting with his aides and allies who were surprised by the presidential edict.

Mr. Trump’s instinct is sound. Americans never voted to be the world’s policemen or cried out to be fixers in the Middle East.

But a simple objective does not imply a straightforward means. The president’s decision has made the situation in Syria an even messier moral and strategic quagmire. The sudden troop withdrawal has exacerbated the geopolitical nightmare in that region and forced the U.S. to abandon an ally in the process.

The U.S. must work to remove itself from the forever wars. But a changed policy is work. It involves careful planning and consideration to ensure the protection of key allies and their people.

We have not made things better in Syria, for the Kurds or even for the Turks. Our tinkering has made things worse, and now our rashness.