Addressing Congress in 1950 about a set of proposed laws meant to punish dissent and “subversion,” President Harry Truman issued an ominous warning: “Once a government is committed to the principle of silencing the voice of opposition, it has only one way to go.”
Free expression is a fundamental right and perhaps the most essential American value. It gives each person a voice and a chance to be heard, free from government suppression. This freedom has led to the creation of masterful works of art, the advancement of important social and political causes, and the furthering of our collective understanding of the people and world around us.
The advent of the internet was a momentous development for free expression. Its singular power to connect people of all kinds has transformed the world, democratizing communication and offering everyone the opportunity to amplify their words and ideas.
That is what makes a draft of a Trump administration executive order, leaked in early August, so troubling.
The draft order, were it signed into effect by President Donald Trump, would give the Federal Communications Commission new powers to shape policies regarding how social media websites curate content on their platforms. It would also authorize the Federal Trade Commission to take these policies into account when investigating companies or filing lawsuits.
In other words, the order would authorize the federal government to create and enforce rules about what speech is allowed on the internet.
While the Trump administration has declined to offer a statement on the leaked draft, a spokesperson pointed CNN to comments made by the president during a July summit held at the White House with right-wing social media personalities. Mr. Trump promised to “explore all regulatory and legislative solutions to protect free speech.”
But the draft executive order would not protect free speech — in fact, it would do the opposite. As Evan Greer, deputy director of Fight for the Future, a nonprofit digital rights advocacy group, has argued: “In practice, it means whichever party is in power can decide what speech is allowed on the internet.”
There are real and substantive questions about how best to balance the needs of free speech with the perils of the internet. The spread of hate speech that incites violence, as well as graphic content like the Christchurch massacre video, has sparked important conversations about how best to handle hateful content online.
But these questions will require exhaustive debate and, very likely, may never be answered. What is certain, however, is that the government should never be in the business of censorship. As Truman warned, it is a slippery slope once the censorship begins.
Mr. Trump’s draft executive order is shortsighted, misguided and, in all likelihood, unconstitutional. The government should keep its nose out of online speech and Mr. Trump should throw that draft in the trash.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.