The Talmud, the ancient compendium of Jewish commentary on civil and religious law, holds that courts which impose the death penalty even rarely could be considered “bloodthirsty”: Justice should not require additional bloodletting to be served.

Thus, earlier this month, leaders and members from two of the Jewish congregations that were brutally attacked in last year’s massacre at the Tree of Life synagogue (which encompasses three congregations) called upon Attorney General William Barr and his team of federal prosecutors to refrain from seeking the death penalty for the suspect in the shooting, which claimed 11 lives.

While their request was not heeded — the Justice Department announced Aug. 26 that it would seek the death penalty for Robert Bowers, the suspect in the crime — the congregants’ request is a model for the spirit, if not the letter, of our laws. Their plea speaks of the highest moral law, in which only God can judge because only God is God. And it suggests the ultimate social compact — the one we are not close to achieving — in which forgiveness is the final word.

Mr. Barr has one duty. Members of the Tree of Life see another, larger one for us all.

Advertise with us

The recent letters from the New Light Congregation and Congregation Dor Hadash do not cite statistics or notable previous cases involving the death penalty. Instead, the writers offer theological and deeply personal objections to the death penalty — highlighting the human arrogance of an “eye for an eye.”

Rabbi Jonathan Perlman, of New Light Congregation, argued that prosecutors should put the killer behind bars for life so that the general public can then focus on positive (even holy) responses to the shootings, including the courage of the police who responded to the attack and the integrity of the Jewish medical staff who treated the alleged shooter.

Indeed, the large spirit of these congregations is akin to the profound integrity shown by first responders and medical professionals on that awful day. What they all had in common was that they stood for life.

Like the Amish community’s act of forgiveness after the 2006 Lancaster County shooting that claimed the lives of five young girls, the ability of the New Light and Dor Hadash congregants to look beyond their immediate pain is a sign of hope and light.

In the face of outrageous injustice, humanity cries out for justice. But law is not justice. It cannot be. Justice is something wider and deeper. Eventually all human beings, and all human societies, must discover that the true path to justice is mercy.