When it comes to the announced shutdown of Polk Center, about 90 minutes north of Pittsburgh, the overseers of this state institution for the intellectually disabled — one of the few of its kind remaining in Pennsylvania — should be looking for middle ground. And that ground may be found literally on Polk’s 2,000-acre campus in Venango County.

Instead, the state Department of Human Services has said in definitive terms that Polk will be closed and its fewer than 200 residents will be relocated to community-based homes during a three-year shuttering process.

State officials say deinstitutionalization will benefit the Polk residents by giving them a more “home”-like experience than the one they’ve experienced at the institution that was founded more than 100 years ago and once was home to thousands. The state promises that all of Polk residents’ myriad needs will be met in their new homes. And their needs are, indeed, myriad. Most are elderly, and virtually all have complex medical diagnoses in addition to their intellectual challenges.

The relocation will save bundles of precious state dollars that should be shared with thousands of other intellectually disabled persons who are waiting for service of any and all kinds. It costs more than $400,000 per person annually to care for a resident of Polk. The figure drops dramatically in a group-home setting, sometimes by as much as half, according to state figures.

Advertise with us

These are legitimate concerns, and some advocacy groups for the intellectually disabled favor the shutdown for the same reasons articulated by state officials.

But those who are closest to the situation — the families and friends of the Polk residents — are opposed to the idea. They argue the compelling fact that such a move for those at Polk will be disruptive beyond description. For many, it is the only home they have known. And not only will their physical environment change dramatically, their caregivers will, too. All of this is complicated by the well-documented fact that many community-based group homes struggle with high staff turnover and significant staff shortages.

The families are not alone in their opposition. Employees, who number around 730, are concerned about their jobs. Elected officials are worried about their constituents.

It makes sense to close the cavernous Polk Center. It no longer fits its population. It makes sense to sell off most of the sprawling campus that’s just a few miles from Interstate 80 and the intersection with I-79 — potentially prime real estate. It makes sense to reduce the astronomically high per-person cost of caring for Polk residents when so many are waiting for help and there is not an unlimited pool of dollars.

But this need not be an all-or-nothing proposition. There must be room for some creative thinking.

Advertise with us

For example, why can’t a corner of Polk grounds be subdivided from the massive tract and a building or two — smaller, homier — be constructed on the parcel? Residents would enjoy the comfort of familiar faces, their fellow residents. And some of the same caregivers currently employed at Polk could be retained. The shutdown process of the larger center could proceed and those who want alternative placement could be moved. Those who want to remain could be shifted to the new quasi-Polk of a more suitable size. The saved costs as well as proceeds from the sale of the land could be used to subsidize construction. Caregiving costs will follow the residents no matter where they are living.

This may not be the definitive answer, but there should be a real purpose to the public hearing scheduled at Polk for 1 p.m. on Monday, Sept. 9. That purpose should not be solely to allow residents’ families to vent. It should be to allow state officials to listen — really listen. Perhaps in the act of conversing, some alternative ideas will surface.