In an age defined by rampant cultural volatility and the eerie encroachment of technology, baseball has remained one of the few constants, offering fans a relaxing and endearing game that has changed very little since the 19th century.

But, because our society seems unable to leave anything alone, baseball is now bracing itself for its most radical change in decades — robot umpires.

Yes, that’s right, our national pastime’s balls and strikes could soon be determined by a computer.

The Atlantic League of Professional Baseball, an independent league, has been experimenting with the use of an automated strike zone. A human umpire stands behind the plate wearing an earpiece connected to a phone. The umpire then relays the call from a tracking system that uses Doppler radar.

Advertise with us

Proponents of the robo umpire claim that the technology will lead to more accurate calls and fairer games. Blown calls can undermine entire games as well as hurt individual players and their statistics. Arguing with umpires over bad calls slows the entire game down, something professional baseball executives fret about often these days. And there is little question that this technology can technically perform more accurately than a human.

But is that accuracy and saved time worth sacrificing the human element of baseball?

One of the great joys of baseball, and certainly one of its most entertaining components, is the interplay between the players, coaches and umpires. The fallibility of everyone involved makes the sport relatable, as well as exciting. Arguing with the umpire, justified or not, makes for exciting viewing. It also injects a psychological element into the game that can inflate or deflate a team (lest we forget Jerry Meals’ dreadful botched call in July 2011 that cost the Pirates a 19-inning game against the Atlanta Braves, sending the Pirates into a tailspin for the rest of that season).

Human umpires are also not unacceptably inaccurate. A 2019 Boston University study found that home plate umpires made the right ball-strike call nearly 91% of the time in 2018. That figure has been trending upward in recent years, a fact some attribute to more selective hiring practices.

And for those unconcerned about baseball, imagine how this technology could be extrapolated to impact your sport of choice. Robots could soon be making the calls on the football field and basketball court, not to mention phasing out human workers at retail stores or warehouses.

So while it may seem trivial, robot umpires do not bode well for the future of the beloved game of baseball nor for society. Handing more and more responsibilities over to automatons is a recipe for disaster. Let us retain some sliver of humanity and forget the robot umpires.