In an unexpected move that has a suspicious sniff of political brinkmanship, the Bethel Park School Board did an about-face and cut the property tax rate for the 2019-20 fiscal year.
Lower taxes can sound like a good thing — unless they sacrifice long-term financial sustainability.
It’s hard to tell in this case because there was no public discussion of the tax cut nor did administrators present an analysis of the impact for public review.
The panel voted, 6 to 3, in late June to reduce the tax rate by 8%. The lost revenue will be replaced by pulling about $5 million from the district’s unassigned fund balance — a sort of safety net for emergency expenditures — to compensate for the budget’s revenue loss.
Members of the teachers union as well as opponents on the board decried the move, the motion for which was made by a board member who failed to win nomination in the May primary and, therefore, will not be on the November election ballot.

The preliminary budget had called for a continuation of the current tax rate.
Cutting taxes doesn’t just reduce revenue for the coming year; it reduces the bases on which future revenue is generated. The impact can be far-reaching.
The June 25 vote was a strange and unexpected — at least from the standpoint of the public — reversal of a previous plan that had been presented and endorsed by district administrators. The board already had approved a preliminary budget that held the millage rate at 22.8763 mills. Then, all of a sudden and to the obvious surprise of some board members, director Ron Werkmeister — an incumbent who failed to secure a nomination in the May primary election — moved to cut the tax rate to 21 mills. There had not been any public discussion about such a move during months of preparations for what was to be an $89 million spending plan.
Board members Ken Nagel, Barry Christenson and Pamela Dobos voted no to the tax cut. In favor were board President Donna Cook, Mr. Werkmeister, David Amaditz, Connie Ruhl, Cynthia Buckley and Jim Means. Of those voting in favor of lowering the tax rate, only Mr. Means and Mr. Christenson are among incumbents who will be on the November election ballot.
It is irresponsible for a board to make such a drastic move without analysis of the long-term financial impact by district administrators —- the salaried professionals who get paid precisely for such input. A written statement by Superintendent Joseph Pasquerilla — an employee who reports to the board — notes: “The administration put the motion on the agenda to pass the 2019-2020 budget with a zero millage increase, but the final budget that is adopted is ultimately the board’s decision. It is the administration’s job to work within the budget parameters the board sets.” It reads like a man trying to appease his bosses.
The union representing Bethel Park teachers called the tax cut “short-sighted” and “irresponsible.” The union had hoped that some of the district’s budgetary reserve would have been used to fund some new hires.
Some local governments accrue fund balances that are unnecessarily high. But others — in an attempt to appease taxpayers in the short-term — operate on a frayed string. Finding the middle ground should be the result of a very public and thorough budget process — a process that was undertaken in Bethel Park and that resulted in a recommendation for a spending plan that held the line. A reversal — sudden, without public discussion or input from administrators — is both unwise and contrary to sound policymaking.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.