As Boeing officials wheeled and dealed at this year’s Paris Air Show, the aviation industry’s largest trade fair, a group of witnesses and experts appeared before Congress to criticize Boeing’s handling of the 737 Max 8 scandal.
The plane, a best-seller for Boeing, crashed twice in less than five months. Those accidents — a Lion Air flight in Indonesia in October and an Ethiopian Airlines flight in March that left a combined 346 people dead — sparked an investigation into the plane’s design and how well pilots were prepared to fly the aircraft.
It was revealed that Boeing did not include a particular cockpit warning light in every model of the Max 8. The light, which was supposed to inform pilots if a new piece of software that could automatically move the nose of the plane was malfunctioning, was an optional extra that airlines could purchase. Neither Lion Air nor Ethiopian Airlines had purchased the light.
Furthermore, Boeing knew that this new software, known as the Maneuvering Characteristic Augmentation System, was susceptible to malfunction — forcing the plane into a nosedive — for about a year, initially deciding that the issue “did not adversely impact airplane safety or operation.”
The failure of the MCAS software and pilots’ inability to respond to it — Boeing only mandated pilots take a two-hour iPad course, which made no mention of MCAS, before operating the Max 8 — are believed to have played a significant role in both the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes, though final reports are pending.
Boeing CEO Dennis Muilenburg admitted June 16 at the Paris Air Show that the company’s handling of the situation had been a “mistake.”
But corporate behavior that leads to the deaths of 346 people cannot simply be waved away as a mistake. Members of the Allied Pilots Association, the union representing American Airlines pilots, as well as other aviation experts and family members of victims from the Max 8 crashes, made this clear during congressional testimony June 19.
Retired Capt. Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger, who famously landed a damaged US Airways jet on the Hudson River in New York in 2009, told Congress that the MCAS “was fatally flawed and should never have been approved.”
He described the difficulty he experienced flying a Max 8 simulator, which triggered the MCAS unexpectedly. “I can tell you firsthand that the startle factor is real and it’s huge,” he said. “It absolutely interferes with one’s ability to quickly analyze the crisis and take corrective action.”
With the company busy doing damage control and taking orders for the Max 8 at the Paris Air Show, no Boeing representatives testified at the hearing.

The company’s response to this scandal has been disgraceful. Mr. Muilenburg and his staff appear to have not reckoned with the consequences of their actions. Hundreds of people were killed as the result of an inherent flaw with the Max 8’s design that Boeing had hidden, and the company still tried to keep the plane in service before the public pressure became too much.
Congress must issue subpoenas and compel Boeing officials to answer essential questions about the company’s handling of the Max 8, from start to finish. Drag them kicking and screaming if necessary, but the American people — and people all over the world — deserve accountability from those who allowed people to board unsafe planes.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.