If the Dominican Republic wants to preserve its tourism industry, officials and hospitality leaders there had better step up efforts to explain the deaths of at least nine American visitors over the past year.
Each day, it seems, brings fresh stories of American tourists who died or were sickened while visiting the Caribbean nation’s resorts. Several purportedly succumbed to heart-related conditions even though they were comparatively young, and some resorts have had more than one American death.
The victims include a recently engaged Maryland couple, Nathaniel Holmes, 63, and Cynthia Ann Day, 49, who died of what authorities in the Dominican Republic called respiratory failure. The two were found in their hotel room at the same time. Both had fluid in their lungs.
As Rutgers University toxicologist Reynold A. Panettieri Jr. told People, “Healthy people don’t just die. And the couple dying at the same time certainly tips us off that something is very wrong.”

The website for the Dominican Republic’s embassy in Washington, D.C., describes tourism as “one of the most important economic activities” in the country — one that’s fueled a wave of hotel construction in recent years. However, the website says not one word about the recent deaths and offers no advice for Americans due to travel there. Nor does the Dominican Republic’s tourism website offer anything but paeons to the country’s beauty and accessibility.
A government tourism adviser told The Washington Post that the Dominican Republic’s bureaucracy isn’t used to responding to public relations problems of this magnitude and hired crisis management specialists. So far, those specialists appear to be invisible.
While some hotels have expressed sympathy for the American deaths, one, Bahia Principe Hotels & Resorts, issued a tone-deaf statement saying “we completely disagree with the dissemination of false information” that “threatens the image and reputation of the company and the integrity and rights of our employees and their families.”
The company added that it is “reserving, where necessary, the right to take the appropriate legal action.” This sounds like a hotel chain to avoid at all costs.
Some speculate that tainted alcohol is to blame for the deaths and others have suggested the overuse of pesticides is involved. The Dominican Republic faces a stark choice: It can address the crisis head-on, as Tylenol successfully did with the 1982 tampering cases, or it can bumble the controversy and the investigation, as Aruba did with the 2005 disappearance of Natalee Holloway, with long-term damage to the country’s image.
While the FBI has stepped in to help investigate the deaths, the U.S. government’s overall response also has been disappointing. The State Department’s travel advisory for the Dominican Republic cautions visitors about the prevalence of crime in some areas but says nothing about the mysterious deaths.
Until the Dominican Republic can provide answers, or at least a measure of reassurance, Americans might want to rethink vacations there. While the details remain elusive, there is clearly trouble in paradise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.