China’s rising ambition for global political influence is on display in Hong Kong, where legislators allied with the mainland are now trying to gain one-sided extradition power from the semi-independent mercantile island.
Ideally, mainland China and Hong Kong should have a close enough relationship that criminal defendants can be transported to a court to face justice.
After all, the states of the United States extradite to each other, and the United States has extradition treaties with many international entities, including Hong Kong.
Yet, such is the lack of trust in China that the proposed law has generated massive protests and even physical altercations in the Hong Kong legislature.
China took over Hong Kong in 1997 after years of British rule, agreeing to respect Hong Kong’s laws, courts, currency and civil service.
The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, which advises Congress, stated that the law would “increase the territory’s susceptibility to Beijing’s political coercion and further erode Hong Kong’s autonomy.”
The commission noted that the rule does not include mutual extradition rights with the mainland.
The commission said the change in extradition law “could pose significant risk to U.S. national security and economic interests in the territory,” allowing “Beijing to pressure the Hong Kong government to extradite U.S. citizens under false pretenses.”
The commission warned that U.S. Navy personnel could be at risk when in port calls.
China is embarked on a campaign to expand global power and clamp down on domestic personal liberty. China uses economic threats and military intimidation to grow its sovereignty claims in the South China Sea. It represses the semiautonomous Uighur population in western China with “re-education” camps. The free internet is blocked in China. China arrested two Canadians in a transparent retaliation for the arrest in Canada of the daughter of a prominent Chinese businessman.
Extradition between two states or nations is a privilege enjoyed by countries that respect each other’s criminal justice process.
Rather than abuse its influence in Hong Kong, China would do well to demonstrate first that it respects the rights of the criminally accused.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.