The National Security Agency’s phone data surveillance program, conceived in the wake of 9/11 and a near continual source of controversy for the intelligence agency, is finally on its way out.
According to a report by The Wall Street Journal, NSA officials have formally recommended ending the program, noting that its “logistical and legal burdens” outweigh any intelligence benefits.
This development is, unquestionably, a good thing.
Journalist James Bamford estimated in 2008 that the NSA was collecting 48 petabytes of intelligence data each year through its surveillance program. This is a staggering amount of information, equivalent to 24 trillion pages of text. The NSA was apparently unconcerned with whom it was monitoring or what it was collecting — former NSA Director Keith Alexander once directed his agency to “collect it all.”

So any narrowing of the NSA’s data accumulation efforts would appear to be a good thing, even if it is coming almost two decades too late.
But before anyone starts praising the NSA for finally heeding the concerns of the American people, the majority of whom disapproved of the phone surveillance program, it is important to recognize that the NSA is merely adjusting its tactics rather than entirely scrapping its intrusive “collect it all” approach.
Read More
In recent years, polls have consistently shown that younger Americans are eschewing phone calls, choosing to have their conversations via text or through apps like Facebook or Snapchat.
Meanwhile, the smart speaker business has boomed in the U.S. There are approximately 118 million of those devices in American homes now.
So why would the NSA go through the hassle of snooping on phone calls, which requires an extensive surveillance infrastructure, when it could just more closely monitor activity through apps or speakers that users have already consented to being listened to or watched by?
Americans’ concern for their own privacy has degraded considerably over the past two decades, as the post-9/11 political culture prioritized the vague notion of “national security” over privacy. This was initially manifested in legislation like the Patriot Act, but has since trickled down to social media and consumer electronics.
Now, people are content to hand over reams of personal information to private companies in return for a modest service or a nifty gizmo. The NSA, undoubtedly pleased to see that most of the hard work has already been done, is more than capable of secretly accessing the data provided to companies like Facebook and Amazon.
Or, more likely, it could strike a deal with these companies for access to this data. It did the same thing with phone companies like AT&T for the phone surveillance program.
So while the end of the NSA’s phone surveillance program is better than nothing, Americans should find little solace in its demise because the underlying strategy behind the program has not changed. Rather than snooping on phone calls, the NSA will now be looking at Snapchats or listening to what you said near Amazon’s Alexa. To view this as a laudable development would be like applauding getting punched in the nose after having been kicked in the teeth.
People must recommit themselves to protecting their privacy, from private corporations and government agencies alike. The overlap between the two is likely to grow in the nea -future and, unless action is taken soon, we may not have a reasonable expectation of privacy anywhere at all.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.