America’s heroes, from George Washington on down, have reflected the greatness and flaws of their times.
This is true also of Kate Smith, who gave voice to America’s World War II efforts and buoyed the nation’s spirit during uncertain days. She should be honored for who she was and what she gave the nation despite her flaws.
When she died at 79 in 1986, Smith was one of the nation’s best-known singers. According to a story recounted in the singer’s New York Times obituary, President Franklin D. Roosevelt introduced her to England’s King George VI by saying, “This is Kate Smith. Miss Smith is America.”

Smith cemented her place in history during WWII, when her performances of Irving Berlin’s “God Bless America” helped to raise hundreds of millions of dollars in war bonds. Much later, she sang the song at a handful of Philadelphia Flyers’ games, causing a sensation. The team seemed to play up a notch when she performed or when her recording of “God Bless America” was played before the puck dropped. The Flyers and New York Yankees, continued to play her recordings for decades after her death.
Until now. The Flyers and Yankees have silenced her contralto, and the Flyers first covered up Smith’s statue outside their stadium then removed it. Why? Because a fan alerted the Yankees to racist titles and lyrics in a couple of Smith’s most ancient songs.
Never mind that there’s some question as to whether one of the songs was intended as satire or that her statue was, as the Philadelphia Inquirer reported, one of the few in that city honoring women.
Never mind, as the Inquirer also reported, that Smith called for racial tolerance on a 1945 radio show. Smith appeared on radio shows thousands of times and was known as the “first lady of radio.” What she said mattered.
It evidently did not occur to the Flyers or Yankees that Smith was a product of her times or that history is best remembered, confronted and addressed, not obliterated when its subjects are out of favor, Soviet Union-style. The teams’ mindless overreaction is the same as that which led to the removal of the Stephen Foster statue in Oakland last year.
Ernie Troiano Jr., the mayor of Wildwood, N.J. has offered to take Smith’s statue and pledged to continue playing her recording of “God Bless America” on the city’s boardwalk every day. Is he condoning racism? No, just giving Smith and her place in history the thoughtful treatment they deserve. Good for him.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.