New York’s creation of a commission to investigate misconduct by district attorneys should rekindle interest in the “public integrity commission” previously proposed for Pennsylvania.
In New York, the commission was created to counter the enormous power and limited oversight that enable bad prosecutors to do great damage. Pennsylvania also has had its share of bad apples:
The Bedford County district attorney, William Higgins, resigned last year and pleaded guilty to obstructing the administration of law and other offenses after he was accused of outing confidential informants, protecting drug dealers and offering favorable treatment to defendants with whom he was having sex. The Mercer County district attorney, Miles Karson, also was forced from office and convicted of obstruction after he was charged last year with trying to influence a criminal case involving a romantic partner. And the state’s previous elected attorney general, Kathleen Kane, resigned after she was convicted of leaking grand jury testimony to damage a political enemy and lying about it.
It makes a person wonder what other corruption is out there. A public integrity commission might be just the mechanism for finding out.
The idea has been bandied about for years, but legislators — surprise, surprise — have been cool to the idea. The commission would operate as a bona fide law enforcement agency with power to investigate corruption at the state and local levels. That includes investigating not only prosecutors but legislators, executive-branch officials, judges, mayors and members of school boards and municipal authorities.
The current attorney general, Josh Shapiro, has made fighting public corruption one of his priorities. But not all attorneys general have done so, and there’s no telling what the future may bring. Over the years, the U.S. attorney’s office in Pittsburgh has disappointed with its scarcity of public-corruption cases.
Pennsylvania also has an Ethics Commission to enforce ethics laws and a Judicial Conduct Board to investigate complaints about judges. However, the ethics board traditionally has been underfunded and given insufficient authority while the conduct board has had a reputation for lethargy.
The creation of a public integrity commission could combine some of these functions in one place, with a stronger mandate, a suitable budget and a staff experienced in law enforcement. It would be worth exploring if only because of the potential benefits a new approach would bring.
In New York, local prosecutors have threatened legal action to detail the new commission’s work. Of course they have. Government doesn’t like sunlight, and that’s why Pennsylvania lawmakers have been happy to repeatedly let the proposal for a public integrity commission die on the vine.
But New York’s efforts should stiffen backbones here. A public integrity commission would help make sure that public servants remain just that.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.