Your employer picks your doctor and your medical care, outcome and satisfaction improve. It seems unlikely, but it’s what one health-care model nationwide has found to be successful.
With employer health care costs rising 44 percent between 2007 and 2016, new approaches to traditional insurance plans are being sought.
The Centers of Excellence strategy, used by some large national employers such as Walmart, is not brand new but is growing in popularity. It has enabled the companies to hold down their medical costs and provide good quality treatment to get workers back on the job quicker.
In essence, the companies offer insurance that allows employees to have a primary doctor but requires them to use the designated Centers of Excellence doctors, clinics and hospitals for specified complicated medical care, such as spinal or bariatric surgery or hip or knee replacements. Those centers are selected based on a rigid look by the employer at performance, cost and outcome of patient care.

At Walmart, employees sometimes are flown, at company expense, to the approved providers for consultation, where doctors might decide therapy or other treatment is better than surgery. If the employee wants to pursue the surgery anyway, that can be done, though at a considerable cost to the worker.
Only a portion of Walmart’s 1.4 million employees are in this program, but 5,000 have used it in the past five years when costly surgery was an option. More than half of the candidates for spinal surgery, for example, didn’t need the surgery and obtained other treatment that resulted in good recoveries. It saved the company’s self-insured plan an average of $30,000 for each surgery.
Gerald Kominski, a senior fellow at the University of California, Los Angeles Center for Health Policy Research, is not connected to the Walmart plan but said the model works for large employers which have the leverage to negotiate bundled reimbursement prices from high-quality medical providers. The overall data examining such programs does not indicate patients are being denied needed care, he said, and the patient care outcome at Centers of Excellence is better, on average, than at local hospitals.
But there are concerns. Under Walmart’s program, medical providers are allocated a set amount in costly surgery cases, and the reimbursement typically is less than the cost of surgery. Providers must be discouraged from opting out of surgery and instead using a cheaper alternative treatment just to make money. The program has to ensure the prescribed course of action provides the best medical outcome for the patient.
In a nation with a poorly functioning and rising cost private sector health care system, this program is worth consideration by all employers and employees.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.