Last month, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and UPMC CEO Jeffrey Romoff were photographed in a celebratory handshake as they feted the groundbreaking on the first part of a $2 billion plan to build three state of the art specialty hospitals in Pittsburgh.
As the face of Allegheny County government, Mr. Fitzgerald likely will get invitations to the facilities’ opening day ribbon-cuttings. But, unless he switches medical insurance plans between now and then, he won’t be able to cross the doorway as a patient at any of them.
That’s because Mr. Fitzgerald, like 3-million-plus people in Western Pennsylvania, has Highmark insurance and those subscribers are personas non grata at UPMC.
This should make Mr. Fitzgerald fighting mad. But instead of clenching his fists, he’s throwing his hands in the air. “I don’t like it but there’s not much I can do about it,” he said.
“It” refers to UPMC’s refusal to do business with Highmark. A five-year consent decree that allowed for some cross-network access for certain “vulnerable” patients — aren’t all sick people vulnerable? — expires June 30. And with rare exception, the divorce will be final, with no visitation rights.
Some would say this makes no sense for UPMC. In actuality, it makes all the sense in the world if UPMC’s goal is to suffocate its only significant competition: Highmark, on the insurance side, and Allegheny Health Network, on the provider/facilities side. UPMC has become both the dominant insurer and the dominant health care provider in the region. If Highmark subscribers aren’t allowed to access UPMC doctors and hospitals, those subscribers may switch to a national insurance plan that is accepted both by UPMC and AHN facilities, siphoning some business from Highmark. Or, better yet for UPMC, Highmark defectors may pick up UPMC insurance and commit to funding both the insurance and provider ends of the UPMC behemoth.
Read More
Mr. Fitzgerald should be mustering his political clout to wrangle the parties to the talking table. He should use his bully pulpit to condemn this slow-motion train wreck. Think about it: If UPMC prevails in its game of crush and conquer, lots of Allegheny County residents lose their jobs; lots of tax-exempt land owned by AHN sits vacant. And that’s aside from the obvious: patients’ lost access to facilities that the community helped to build by virtue of foregone tax revenue and charitable donations.
Mr. Fitzgerald may not have authority over UPMC but he likely has some sway over Mr. Romoff, the architect of the strategem for dominion.
“Within local government, we have no power or authority to order anybody to do anything,” Mr. Fitzgerald said in a recent conversation. “It’s state level.”
He then went on to describe UPMC’s “vibrancy”: its enormous investment in Pittsburgh and the rippling impact of that investment.
His high praise leaves us wondering if he’s blinded by UPMC’s sparkle.
The truth is that UPMC contributes much to the region, and it should. It operates under the shield of nonprofit status. It is a charity, benefiting from the charity of others (both citizens and philanthropic foundations.) It receives millions upon millions of dollars in federal grants. It purports to serve the higher mission of life-changing medicine. In sum, it owes us.
Mr. Fitzgerald may not have authority over UPMC but he likely has some sway over Mr. Romoff, the architect of the strategem for dominion.
The county executive acknowledges he “crosses paths” with Mr. Romoff at least once a month. He said he’s “had discussions” about the cross-network-access mess but he declined to provide details and said he “can’t remember the last time I brought it up.” This despite the fact that Mr. Fitzgerald said he “absolutely believes if you have an insurance card, you should be able to go to any facility, particularly facilities built by charitable contributions and taxpayer-funded mechanisms.”
Mr. Fitzgerald is running for reelection. (He said he has received about $5,000 in political contributions this year and last year from UPMC employees — $3,000 of which came from Mr. Romoff in each year. He’s gotten about $10,000 this year and last from Highmark and $5,000 this year from Highmark or AHN employees. Last year, his campaign raised about $800,000 total, he said.)
So Mr. Fitzgerald is not beholden to UPMC. He is free to serve the public and to do the right thing. He needs to start doing it and this means finding his voice, and speaking out about UPMC as well as speaking to UPMC. The message: Come to the table.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.