There are lots of particulars unknown about the contretemps between Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner, her husband and Detroit police at a fancy hotel in March.
But, one thing seems clear to the casual observer: the filing of felony criminal charges against this 41-year-old mom of two elementary school kids — hauling her to a police station, handcuffed, in her pajamas and socks — seems over the top.
Some background: Ms. Wagner, 41, who is running unopposed for re-election to a third term as the county’s fiscal watchdog, and her husband, Khari Mosley, went to Detroit for a post-Valentine’s Day celebration in March. They spent the evening at a concert and dinner. Their night on the town included some consumption of wine. All of this, they have recounted in interviews.
It seems that when the couple returned to their hotel, Ms. Wagner went to bed. Her husband went to the hotel bar. He left his room key in his room. Because he has a different last name then his wife, who had booked the room under her name, the hotel staff declined to give him entrance.

One thing led to another and police were summoned to deal with a “disturbance” created by Mr. Mosley. Authorities’ word.
The details are fuzzy but Mr. Mosley ended up in handcuffs in front of his wife.
Here the specifics are disputed but all agree Ms. Wagner touched a police officer. She ended up on the floor then in the back seat of a police cruiser, which took her to the police station.
What an unfortunate mess.
We don’t know whether the hotel staff handled Mr. Mosley properly. But, he shouldn’t have created a “disturbance.” And, ideally, Ms. Wagner would have kept her cool despite seeing him in handcuffs.
She should have reflected on the fact that every state in the union has a crimes code that makes criminal any kind of an “assault” on a police officer — and the definition of “assault” is broad. Spitting on a police officer can result in an aggravated assault charge. Just touching a police officer can be deemed assault. The premise is that police officers are to be unobstructed in their efforts to “protect and serve.”
While the law is black and white, prosecutors have discretion: Not every criminal charge that can be filed must be filed.
The Wayne County prosecutor’s office charged Ms. Wagner with two felony counts of resisting and obstructing the police and one misdemeanor count of disorderly conduct. Ms. Wagner’s husband was charged with one count each of disorderly conduct and disrupting the peace, both misdemeanors. This was within law enforcement’s power. But it was not right. The couple has pleaded not guilty.
There was a middle ground in this siutation and prosecutors should have used their discretion. If charges were necessary (and that’s debatable), Mr. Mosley could have been cited with summary counts, equivalent to a traffic ticket. Ms. Wagner could have been put in her place with a misdemeanor or two. That would have been significant enough to send a message to the public not to mess with the men in blue.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.