Since the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act was signed into law in 2005, gun manufacturers have been largely shielded against liability when their weapons are used to kill.
But a ruling last week by the Connecticut Supreme Court that will allow a lawsuit against Remington, the manufacturer of the Bushmaster XM15-E2S semiautomatic rifle used in the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre, identified a sound legal argument that could be used to hold gun makers accountable for appealing to people’s worst instincts.
The Sandy Hook victims’ families have alleged that Remington violated the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act by advertising the Bushmaster rifle in a way that promoted its “militaristic and assaultive qualities.” And while the PLCAA does offer the gun industry a great deal of cover, it also allows for lawsuits if a gun maker or dealer broke state or federal laws when selling or marketing the weapon. This lawsuit contends that Remington did just that.
The lawsuit claims that Remington’s marketing invoked acts of war and made deliberate appeals to insecure young men with slogans like “Consider your man card issued.” The families believe the gun manufacturer should have foreseen that its “unethical and irresponsible marketing practices” could lead to a massacre such as the one at Sandy Hook, which claimed the lives of 26 students and staff, including 20 children between 6 and 7 years old. (The perpetrator also killed his mother, though that was prior to the shooting at the school.)
The lawsuit has predictably drawn a significant amount of criticism from the gun lobby. The National Rifle Association, which lobbied heavily for the PLCAA, argued that the case could “eviscerate” the gun industry’s legal protections.
But the justices of the Connecticut Supreme Court were fittingly judicious in allowing this lawsuit to move ahead. A number of other lawsuits that targeted Remington were thrown out because they did not comport with the PLCAA. It was only this particular case, arguing that Remington employed a dangerous advertising strategy, that was approved for litigation.
Read More
It is hard to say if the lawsuit will succeed. But certainly it is fair and just for the Connecticut Supreme Court to allow a jury to hear the case. And the ingenuity of the victims’ families, who threaded a legal needle in an effort to achieve some measure of accountability, should be applauded as well.
This ruling proves that no industry is impervious from challenge. Now, a jury will get to decide if the victims’ families really have a case.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.