In preparing for demonstrations that could erupt during or after the Michael Rosfeld trial, law enforcement officials must keep in mind the many mistakes officers made in 2009 during the G-20 protests — a blueprint for how not to do things.
Back then, police ordered protesters to leave Oakland, then blocked routes out of the neighborhood and arrested people for failure to disperse. Some officers were accused of excessive force. Some of those arrested were just passing through the neighborhood and not even there to protest. A contingent of Chicago police, brought in to help with crowd control, posed for a “trophy” photo with a University of Pittsburgh student they arrested.
When the dust cleared, the city faced a small mountain of lawsuits that it spent four years litigating. It settled at least 16 suits, the largest, involving 13 plaintiffs, for $488,000. Oh, and two Chicago officers were reprimanded by their own department for the trophy photo.
No one needs any of that again.

The trial of Mr. Rosfeld — the white former East Pittsburgh police officer charged with shooting a black youth, 17-year-old Antwon Rose II, as he fled a traffic stop last summer — is unfolding under intense scrutiny. Protests occurred before and after Mr. Rosfeld’s arrest, so authorities have reason to anticipate additional demonstrations in and around the city. They’ve been preparing for the trial for months.
Parts of streets around the courthouse have been closed to vehicle traffic during the trial. Allegheny County sheriff deputies, who provide security in the courthouse, have received special training and riot gear. City police won’t say what preparations they’ve made, but there are reasons to believe they will comport themselves more professionally than they did during the G-20.
First, the city handled last year’s Antwon Rose protests with skill and sensitivity. Second, public safety spokesman Chris Togneri made a point of saying last week that respect for protesters’ First Amendment rights will be the police bureau’s “guiding principle.” Third, Mayor Bill Peduto is better grounded than his predecessor, the 20-something accidental mayor Luke Ravenstahl, and takes a personal interest in the police bureau’s conduct.
Police should give protesters room to maneuver and keep riot gear-suited officers out of sight unless there’s immediate need for them. The sight of officers with helmets, shields and batons tends to escalate matters, not calm people down.
Protests also could occur outside the city, so other departments also have an obligation to be prepared and to respond professionally. Mr. Rosfeld’s trial is all about how officers interact with members of the community. Heavy-handedness with protesters only inflames the debate.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.